Paper or Plastic?
Paper or Plastic?NBC15 Blog Listing
Paper or Plastic?
Topic Author: Christopher Papst
Posted: 4:22 PM Aug 4, 2008
Replies Posted: 4 comments
Save Email Print
Recent Blog Topics

On the morning of August 1, for the first time, a city exploratory committee met to talk about the future of plastic grocery bags in Madison. These plastic bags are seen by some as an environmental hazard because they are petroleum based products that are not easily recyclable. Cities like Seattle, San Francisco and Ann Arbor already have enacted some kind of ban. Could Madison be next?

The aforementioned committee discussed alternatives to a ban, such as encouraging companies to recycle returned bags, including them in curbside recycling, or just placing a tax on them.

"I think there are viable alternatives and I think there are ways we can eliminate plastic bags at larger stores," said Bruce Dickie who works for the Commission for the Environment. I think the real question is why take the time and spend taxpayer dollars to do it.

I asked Mr. Dickie that question and he admitted that there are larger issues, but this is something that is easy to address. He added that we always need to do the right thing for the environment even if it is really small.

The committee will meet again in about a month after talking to local stores to get their input.

When I look at Madison, I see a wonderful city which I have greatly enjoyed being a part. But, it has its fair share of problems and plastic grocery bags just does not seem to be one of them. I think taxpayer dollars could be put to better use.

What do you think? Am I wrong?

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Email (optional):
Location:
Enter Comments:  
   characters left
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Posted by: Matt Location: Stoughton
This really has nothing to do with your blog but when it comes time to pay for the groceries I like to turn the tables on the cashier. I open my wallet and say, "Paper or plastic?".

Posted by: Jake Location: Madison
Dude- how about this- first, let's see if the Madison city council can ever get an original idea, and if they do, without having to copy some other city's brain trust, then we can actually stop and listen to whatever they're mumbling about. This over regulation by the government is almost to the point of communist socialism, where everybody has to contribute to the system, because that is what the system elite demand, but only the elite benefit from the compliance of the working populace, because the elite don't follow their own rules! So, the way I see it, I'll give up my plastic bags when all the city council stop smoking everywhere they go, quit drinking, drive the speed limit, and walk/ bike to work- otherwise, it is just really an exercise in academica, isn't it, because the socialist government will do what it pleases, and we will just be forced to pay taxes, and follow along anyway.

Posted by: Mike Location: Madison
Chris, I totally agree with Sara- I think the city has more stuff to worry about! Besides, if you can't find a store that recycles them, or a cat owner- the Madison Public Library has in the past taken plastic bags to send library materials home in for patrons who have large cumbersome items, or numerous items that don't travel well loosely. Besides, if the city was really worried about eliminating petroleum based plastics, they would ban city offices from using data CDs to store data! there's more petroleum in one CD than there is in 2.5 bags!

Posted by: Sara Location: Madison
I do think that Mr. Dickie has a point in that people should try to do the right thing for the environment no matter how small. I do think, however, that spending time discussing whether or not to ban plastic bags is not a good use of that time. Doesn't the city have bigger things to worry about? I work downtown, and I can come up with a few things that I see every day that could use some attention if they need some help coming up with something. Not only that, but most places (not all, but most) places will take plastic bags back and recycle them already, and if there's a place that doesn't, then find someone with cats- they'll be more than happy to take the old plastic bags to use for litter disposal. I think the city means well; it's just silly to expend the energy on something like this when there's so much other stuff that needs attention.

Weather Authority
Watch your local weather 24/7.
News Links
Looking for something you saw on NBC 15? Find it here.
Double Dollar Deals
Experience our area's best restaurants at a Half-Off price.
Golf Double Dollar Deals
Experience our area's best golf courses at a Half-Off price.
Family Double Dollar Deals
Experience our area's best businesses at a Half-Off price.
What's On?
Click here to see our program guide.
Perfect Home
Find out how to make your perfect home.
The Health Professional
Find answers to your health questions.
Madison's Biggest Loser
Click here! Find out how you can sign up and change your life!
NBC15 Share Your Holidays
Click Here! Find out how you can help raise 3 million meals!