Sheriff Being Questioned
Sheriff Being Questioned Save Email Print
Reporter: Evrod Cassimy
Email Address: ECassimy@nbc15.com

A | A | A

Posted Monday, February 25 --- 10:00pm

A public hearing Monday has authorities practices on how closely they work along with Immigrant Customs Enforcement, or ICE, in question.

"I believe that all law enforcement agencies and partners in the criminal justice system have an obligation to work together," says Dane County Sheriff, Dave Mahoney, when asked why he reports jailed illegal immigrants to ICE. Mahoney appeared before Dane County's Public Protection and Judiciary Committee.

In 2007, there were 15 hundred bookings per month in Dane County. 286 of those were illegal immigrants and of those, 61 were held by ICE. This has raised several concerns from the public.

"I think that this relationship between the local government and ICE needs to stop because it's creating racial profiling in our communities."

"I'm here to say good work sheriff. Keep it up. I'm proud of what he's doing. There's no reason to let law violators to get away with it."

Illegals fear that any encounter they have with law enforcement could lead to deportation. An ordinance for Dane County created in 2002 prevents law enforcement from asking residents about their immigration status thus putting last years increase in ICE holds under the microscope.

____________________________________________________

Original Story Posted January 25, 2008

Madison: Dane County Jail officials are thinking about not telling Immigration and Customs officials when they arrest certain illegal immigrants.

That's because officials are worried about a severe backlog in the court system; if every illegal immigrant is worried jail time will lead to automatic deportation.

Anthony Delyea is a public defender. The court pays him to represent the poorest defendants. By his count he handles nearly 250 cases a year, and more than a 100 involve illegal immigrants.

Delyea says 98% of his cases never see a courtroom, as his clients take plea deals for reduced sentences. That is changing. "I have three cases that are going to go to trial that would have settled before."

The change occurred at the federal level. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE, is now working to deport illegals convicted of even the smallest crime. "If you enter a plea to something as relatively minor as operating after revocation and you have to serve any jail time you might be deported," says Delyea.

Now the only way to avoid jail time and possible deportation is to go to trial, even with a longshot case. Delyea says trials take time, and they are expensive- both for him and the court system. "When you start thinking about how much that's going to cost it's almost terrifying to me."

"It really surfaced about a couple months ago," says Peter Munoz, the Director of Centro Hispano. He says members of the illegal immigrant community are scared, and they may stop reporting crimes or skip court dates to avoid deportation. "It's creating this tremendous problem, where ICE is actually acting immediately, placing those holds and deporting people."

The topic came up at a meeting of the Dane County Criminal Justice Group. Sheriff Dave Mahoney says for more than three decades they have notified ICE when an illegal immigrant is booked in the jail-usually about 20 times a month.

Most of the time ICE would only put holds on a few. But last fall ICE put detainers on 60% of illegal immigrants in the jail. "When we inquired as to October and November why there was this spike, their response was, we had a significant increase in staff, which resulted in our ability to respond," says Mahoney.

The Sheriff and the District Attorney have agreed to examine the policy to notify ICE about illegal immigrants in the jail.

They say one possibility is to only notifiy ICE about those charged with the most serious offenses.

More Stories
Child Injured by Fireworks

Madison Community Leader Speaks Out Against Increasing Gun Violence

CrimeTracker 15: Man Hit with Baseball Bat

CrimeTracker 15: Union Cab Driver Robbed

CrimeTracker 15: Woman Robbed in Fitchburg

"Public Enemies" - Your Source for Information

Area Fireworks Schedule: 2009

Fourth of July Parade Route In Pardeeville Restored

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Phyllis Location: Madison, WI on Feb 27, 2008 at 12:31 PM
I strongly support Sheriff Mahoney in his handling of ILLEGAL Aliens. What is wrong with our city representatives when they turn a blind eye to people obviously breaking our laws just by being here illegally??? We cannot pick and choose what laws should be upheld - Keep up the good work Sheriff Dave!!! Do not change your approach to dealing with those who choose to break our laws.

Posted by: WaytoGo on Feb 27, 2008 at 12:18 PM
Way to go Madison Police and Mr Mahoney. I wish all areas are as proactive on ILLEGALS, as you have been! Congratulations and keep up the good work. Great to see such support here from your fellow madison neighboors!!!

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Sun Prairie on Feb 26, 2008 at 05:45 PM
By reading the responses here, I just have one question. Are the County Board representives truely represting the masses who voted them into their positions? To me, it appears the are coming up with an ordinance to protect illegal aliens and we should all feel betrayed by the lack of true representation. They are putting illegal aliens above legal residents.

Posted by: G Location: Madison on Feb 26, 2008 at 05:15 PM
Keep up the good work Sheriff Mahoney! If they can't be law abiding citizens, they should go back. Great Job!!!!

Posted by: D on Feb 26, 2008 at 03:27 PM
Send them back. Especially if they can't follow the law. We don't need anymore crime than we already have. They aren't contributing taxpayers anyway.

Posted by: Anonymous on Feb 26, 2008 at 02:31 PM
I think what the sheriff is done is right. If he turns them into ICE, then we the tax payers don't have to pay for them sitting in jail. If they are here illegal then they are not paying income taxes. Thank you sheriff for look out for us legal citzens.

Posted by: Just Amazed !!! Location: Madison on Feb 26, 2008 at 02:08 PM
First, I can't believe the Sheriff had to show up at this meeting to explain that his department's job is to enforce the laws of this community and this country. Second, I can't believe that Dane County has such an ordinance on the books. Two wrongs doesn't mean a free ride? Illegally here and not following the rules of this community. Are you kidding me. How could this possibly be an issue.

Posted by: Jeremy Location: Madison on Feb 26, 2008 at 01:22 PM
Kudos to Sheriff Dave and his staff. What is wrong with people. Should we also give repreive to ILLEGAL drug-trafficking and ILLEGAL child abuse because it is clogging the court system and people are skipping out on their trials...

Posted by: becky Location: whitewater on Feb 26, 2008 at 01:19 PM
I don't understand why the sheriff has to answer for doing his job. Those people are here illegally! We should not be spending any money on them other than to send them back. If they were so worried about staying here they would not be committing crimes. It makes me sick that the crimminal has more rights than any one else.

Posted by: Rob Location: Madison on Feb 26, 2008 at 12:48 PM
Kind of funny that of the 250 cases a year that Delyea handles a year....Almost half of them are from illegal immigrants. If statistics show a trend...then who is really committing the crimes? Maybe deportation is not as negative as people make it out to be. And at the same time, maybe the justice system is in need of some changes to correct the timeliness and cost of cases. Common sense never prevails it seems for law abiding citizens.

Posted by: Paul Location: Madison on Feb 26, 2008 at 11:45 AM
It's funny how some people seem to believe that certian crimes should not be reported. I guess they should put out a list of what laws it's ok to break and which ones are not. Turning over illegals to ICE is no different then turning federal criminals over to the FBI. The law is the law, and law enforcement personnal need to work together with all branches of law enforcement.

Posted by: Anonymous on Feb 26, 2008 at 11:44 AM
Why are we questioning the Sheriff when he is taking care of ILLEGAL ALIENS??? People need to be able to know the differance between an Immigrant and an ILLEGAL immigrant.

Posted by: Ellen Location: Arlington on Feb 26, 2008 at 11:05 AM
Bottom line: The first crime is coming here illegally. If they commit a second crime, no matter how small, they should be deported. They should go home and work to make their home country into something that is livable, just like the pioneers of this country did. If they come illegally and live an otherwise lawful life, chances nobody will catch them and they can stay. Why do we fight for illegal lawbreakers to stay here and steal our jobs and tax-provided benefits?

Posted by: Good Deed Location: Madison on Feb 26, 2008 at 10:54 AM
I would like to thank the Dane County Sheriff's Office for reporting ILLEGAL immigrants. If you do not have the paperwork and committ a crime, I have no problem with ICE deporting that individual. I remember last year when the illeagal immigrants decided to march and see what keep of problems would happen if these individuals did not show up for work. I found it truly amazing that the federal / local goverments did not collapse! As far as Racial Profiling, get over it. If you committ the crime and are caught, that is not racial profiling. It is called stupidity and you deserve to serve the time and be deported. To Sheriff Mahoney, you did break a "County Ordinance" and here is your $25.00 ticket! Keep up the great work and if you keep breaking this ordinance, give me a call and I will help you pay the ticket....Good Deed

Posted by: Dawn Location: Sun Prairie on Feb 26, 2008 at 10:42 AM
If they are here illegally, one can assume they are not paying taxes and coming using our resources without paying for them. If you get caught doing something illegal, send them home!

Posted by: Anon Location: Madison on Feb 26, 2008 at 10:32 AM
Any person in this country illegally should be reported to the proper authorities and deported. You want to live in the United States do it legally and also speak the language of the country you want to live in. Quit making it easier to be in this country by making it easier to stay illegal. We also sponsor health care at no cost to these people and increase our costs as Americans.

Posted by: Terry Location: Madison on Feb 26, 2008 at 10:19 AM
Sheriff Mahoney is doing the right thing. The Dane County Board is doing the wrong thing in passing ordinances that serve to protect those who are in this country without legal basis. It is Sheriff Mahoney's duty to enforce all laws and if a person being booked does not speak english and has no documents to prove who they are it would seem quite obvious that they may be an illegal alien. I hope NBC 15 news follows up on this with information as to what the opinion of ICE is with regard to this ordinance which is in effect banning law enforcement from alerting those Federal authorities with jurisdiction to enforce existing immigration laws.

Posted by: john m fogarty jr Location: sun prairie wi on Feb 26, 2008 at 10:08 AM
sheriff dave- you are the senior law enforcement official in dane county. your job requires the arrest of law breakers. illegal immigrants are by definition law breakers. keep up the good work because all of the non socialist citizens of dane county back you 100%.

Posted by: Dave Location: Dodgeville on Feb 26, 2008 at 08:39 AM
If you are here illegally, and you break one of our laws, you should be sent back to your country. If you are here illegally and are a productive member of society, make an effort to become a citizen, thousands of individuals do it correctly, so should you.

Posted by: Jay Location: Verona on Feb 26, 2008 at 08:08 AM
They should worry that any contact they have with any United States law enforcement will lead to deportation. If they do not want that fear go back to your native country or gain access to this country legally. How many thousands of people gain access legally each year? Yet we should circumvent all the laws for the people that do not want to follow the rules? Nice logic there... I don't want to pay taxes, so please United States circumvent the rules for me too. If you want the laws and rules of this country to apply to you, then gain access legally. Everyone that supports the illegals acts like there is no way into this country outside "sneaking in". Actually, there is. The illegals just need to stop being too lazy to use due process. We have due process in place to attempt to protect American citizens from allowing entry to criminals, rapists, terrorists, and molesters that are citizens of other nations. This let them all in policy is a very risk business.

Posted by: Ric Location: Muscoda on Feb 26, 2008 at 08:02 AM
First, according to Federal law, they are legally supposed to ask if they are illegal immigrants, and they are supposed to report them to federal law. Second, if illegal immigrants are breaking the law, they shouldn't be allowed to stay here. Hopefully, if they are deported, it will cut down on the crime rate here in the united states. One of the reasons they are breaking the law is because they cannot legally obtain jobs, and considering the problems with the job market, no one needs to hire them anyway. I say thank you to Sheriff Mahoney for following Federal laws, which override county ordinances.

Posted by: eddie Location: dane co on Feb 26, 2008 at 06:54 AM
The sheriff is doing the correct thing on illegals. The county board should not have a law that prevents the detained illegals. This is U.S.A. not Mexico and what part of illegal do they (county board) not understand??????? The school tax increase alone for the elderly because of the illegals is high and they should not have to pay for any illegal, period. Or for any other service. Sheriff keep up the good work.

Posted by: legal Location: Madison on Feb 26, 2008 at 06:14 AM
They key here is "illegal" immigrants. I say Good job to Sheriff as well. He enforces the law!

Posted by: DeportMadison Location: Madison on Feb 26, 2008 at 06:12 AM
"Illegals fear that any encounter they have with law enforcement could lead to deportation." They should fear deportation, they are lucky they made it all the way to Wisconsin before being found, they should have been stopped at the border! Do they not realize they do not have to commit additional crimes to be deported, they committed a crime coming here illegally!

Posted by: Deborah Location: Madison on Feb 25, 2008 at 10:55 PM
Keep up the good work Sheriff Mahoney. It seems to me that Dane County, the Madison School District, and UW Hospital just to name a few should be asking those same questions. If they did, maybe we would have the funds to fix our streets, hire more officers, clean our drinking water, or clean up the graffiti that is showcased on East Washington - the "Gateway to Madison" Thanks for doing your job.

Posted by: Don Location: DeForest on Feb 25, 2008 at 10:36 PM
Great Job Mahoney! I agree with what he is doing. The quote in the article, "illegals fear that any encounter they have with law enforcement could lead to deportation" says it all. They are in the USA illegaly and should not be, therefor why not deport them. Obviously our borders can't stop them, why not our local fellow officers!

Weather Authority
Watch your local weather 24/7.
News Links
Looking for something you saw on NBC 15? Find it here.
Double Dollar Deals
Experience our area's best restaurants at a Half-Off price.
Golf Double Dollar Deals
Experience our area's best golf courses at a Half-Off price.
Family Double Dollar Deals
Experience our area's best businesses at a Half-Off price.
What's On?
Click here to see our program guide.
Perfect Home
Find out how to make your perfect home.
The Health Professional
Find answers to your health questions.
Bike MS
Join us as we ride the open road to fight MS
AP Video