Join the NBC15 Facebook network! Search "Wmtv Madison" on Facebook. And click HERE to follow NBC15 News on Twitter!
NBC15 Poll
Do you have plans to enjoy the snow this weekend?

Yes, I am going to be outside.and loving it.
No, I am going stay inside and watch a movie.


UPDATE: Three UW Students Die in Crash Save Email Print
102 comments

Lindsey Plank. Photo courtesy of Facebook.
A | A | A

UPDATED Tuesday, September 23, 2008 --- 10:57 a.m.

The Dane County Coroner says the driver in last month's fatal crash on Midvale Boulevard was drunk.

Richard Putze's blood alcohol concentration was 0.144.

Putze drove into a tree with his passengers, Lindsey Plank and Daniel Myers.

_________________________________________________________

UPDATED Monday, September 8, 2008 --- 5:45pm

From UW-Madison NEWS:

A campus memorial service will be held in memory of Lindsey Plank, Dan Myers and Richard Putze, UW-Madison students who died in an Aug. 27 car accident on Midvale Boulevard.

The service will be held at 8 p.m. on Monday, Sept. 8, at the Red Gym. It is being coordinated by the organization of University Religious Workers in cooperation with the Offices of the Dean of Students.

Friends, family, faculty and staff members are invited to share stories and reflections about lives of the three students. Dean of Students Lori Berquam is also expected to speak.

All three had made a unique mark on campus. Putze and Plank were involved in the Department of Chemistry as volunteer lecture demonstrators. Myers was a talented pianist who had recently become eligible to receive his degree.

“Dan was a piano major in my studio for all four of his years here at UW and was one of the most talented students I've ever had,” reflects Professor Todd Welbourne of the School of Music.

“He was extremely bright and had a unique take on everything he touched. He could toss off a virtuoso Liszt etude with ease, and then turn around and give an in-depth theoretical analysis of complicated 20th century music,” he adds. “He certainly had a bright future waiting for him in the music world. We are all going to miss him so very much.”

Separately, scholarship funds have been set up in the name of Myers in the School of Music and for Plank and Putze in the Department of Chemistry. The chemistry department will also assist anyone wanting to provide funds directly to the families.

_______________________________________________________

UPDATED Wednesday, August 27 --- 5:30pm

MADISON, Wis. (AP) -- Three University of Wisconsin-Madison students are dead after an early morning car crash.

The Dane County Corner's Office identified the victims as 22-year-old Daniel Myers, 23-year-old Lindsey T. Plank and 22-year-old Richard H. Putze.

All three victims were from Madison and killed when their car struck a tree just after 1:45 a.m. Wednesday morning.

University officials say Plank and Putze were seniors majoring in chemistry.

Myers was not enrolled for the fall semester, but completed his degree requirements this summer in music performance.

Madison Police spokesman Howard Payne says alcohol may have been a factor in the crash.

Dean of Students Lori Berquam says the timing of the tragedy is particularly hard just before the new semester begins.

Copyright 2008 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.

_______________________________________________________

UPDATED Wednesday, August 27, 2008 --- 1:05 p.m.

UPDATE: The third occupant has died.

The Dane County Coroner's Office has identified the three victims from the early morning crash in the 200 block of Midvale Boulevard.

They are identified as:
23-year-old Lindsey T. Plank
22-year-old Richard H. Putze
22-year-old Daniel Myers

Richard was pronounced dead at the scene of the crash, and Lindsey was pronounced dead at the U.W. Hospital, due to their injuries.

All three passengers in the car were current students of UW-Madison.

The crash is still under investigation.

_______________________________________________________

UPDATED Wednesday, August 27, 2008 --- 10:15 a.m.

According to the Madison Police Department:

On 8/27/2008 shortly after 1:30am, The Madison Police Department, with assistance from The Madison Fire Department, responded to a single vehicle accident involving a tree. From the preliminary investigation, the involved vehicle was traveling northbound on S. Midvale Boulevard near the 200 block, when this vehicle appears to have lost control and impacted a tree.

As a result of the accident, 2 occupants were pronounced deceased, and 1 occupant remains in critical condition at a local hospital. Seatbelts were used by at least 2 of the occupants. Questions regarding alcohol are also being investigated at this time. This accident remains under investigation by The Madison Police Department Traffic Specialists, and names of occupants are not being released pending notifications of family and the submission of the Coroners’ report.

Victims:
Male, early 20s, deceased
Female, early 20s, deceased
Male, early 20s, critical condition
_________________________________________________________

Posted Wednesday, August 27-- 6:02am

One person is dead after a car crash around 1:45 Wednesday morning.

It happened on the 200 block of South Midvale Boulevard. The Madison Fire Department says a car carrying three passengers hit a tree.

Extrication of two victims was conducted, and both were transported to UW Hospital. Conditions of the victims are unknown at this time. The third victim pronounced dead at the scene by the coroner.

No other word on factors in the crash.

The crash closed parts of Midvale for part of the morning.

All lanes are now open.
More Stories
Your Weekend Forecast

Road Conditions & Snow Emergencies

Fire Destroys Beloit Apartment Building

32nd Deploys for Iraq

 UPDATE: Proposed Bus Fare Increase

Stabbing Investigation

Zimmermann Murder: the 911 Call

CrimeTracker 15: Car & House Windows Shot Out
Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Joe on Dec 21, 2008 at 10:52 PM
Ok Marissa, you have absolutely NO right to be saying anything about John. If you looked up to your brother and if your brother taught you everything you know, you would probably be really upset in this situation. This was his BROTHER. Have some symmpathy. Granted what he said earlier may not have been very nice or correct, cut some slack. This was IMMEDIATE FAMILY and someone he loved has just been ripped from his life and there is nothing he can do. Grow up and cut some slack. You can "shut your mouth bud!"
Posted by: Alanis Location: McFarland on Sep 28, 2008 at 04:35 AM
I am so going to puke if the UW awards the Putze kid a posthumus degree! He died, he killed other people, all through his own stupidity! there is no reason he should have a degree conferred upon him for killing himself in an illegal act that also took the life of two other students! If they do that, then my own degree from UW-Madison will be meaningless, because all I would have had to do would be go out and kill someone to get my degree! And, to make it better, I would have made sure to take out some criminal, not a promising musician, and a promising chemist! he deserves to rot in hell, and he deserves to do it without the honor of a degree from the UW system!
Posted by: Marissa Location: Madison on Sep 26, 2008 at 11:50 AM
Amen Susan! Another thing I have noticed is that John Putze jumped all over someone in another story on this same set of teens on this site a month ago, telling them to "get more facts, bud" yet we all have facts now, and he hasn't showed up to tell any of us to "shut our mouths" like he did in that other story. just go to the search box and typ uw students, and read the stories posted about these three in this accident. it is in there somewhere. John Putze, from Milwaukee, we're waiting...
Posted by: Susan on Sep 25, 2008 at 08:29 PM
Kinda telling that everyone who insisted alcohol could not possibly have been involved has not shown up here to further comment and, I don't know, apologize for jumping all over us.
Posted by: Jasmine Location: Deerfield on Sep 25, 2008 at 02:34 PM
Who cares? he may have been a murdering ass, but it doesn't change anything. I mean, it is not like he can get the death penalty for a double murder or anything. this story is a waste of time anyway. whole bunch of them are dead, who cares, move along. it was preventable. if it had been a bridge collapse, or a roadway blizzard, it would be different, but it was a one car accident with a drunk murderer who, through his idiotic actions killed the two passengers in his car. fine. it's over. move along. nothing to see here anymore. waste of everyone's time anyway. little rich college boy killed himself thinking his crap didn't stink, and he could do what he wanted, when he wanted. sad thing is, for a chemistry major, he sure didn't understand chain reaction events very well! drink, drive, die- heck, little kids recite it off TV. kid must have been really ignorant.
Posted by: stacey Location: madison on Sep 25, 2008 at 07:58 AM
Nicole, regarding your 09/11 comment "To you and all the other "haters" out there that want to assume the worst, I hope you are eating your words if the true cause is ever released!" Nobody wanted to assume the worst, just being realistic given the information that had been released at the time. I am sorry for the loss of these three people to something so preventable and senseless. I wish this incident would "wake people up" but the sad fact of the matter is, it won't. If people do not have a plan to have a designated driver in place BEFORE they have that first drink or two, chances are they will think they are "fine" to drive.
Posted by: Mandi Location: Madison on Sep 24, 2008 at 07:08 PM
think about it- maybe they weren't innocent, but at least they weren't driving. division of negligence can certainly not be argued in this case- no matter who they rode home with, they had no control over the car they occupied. would they be just as "not innocent" if they were drunk & died in a traffic accident involving a cab they took home? or is it just that they chose to ride home with the same drunken murderer that they had been drinking with that makes them "not innocent" in this. I know I feel very strongly that of all the things I can think of this accident, knowing the driver died on the scene, my thoughts revolve around how much I hope his last moments on Earth really, really hurt, to make up for the hours that his friends lingered near death before they finally died due to their injuries. I hope he was conscious of the fact he was dying with each breath. they may not have been innocent Think about it, but they were far from responsible for the act which took their lives.
Posted by: Think about it.... on Sep 24, 2008 at 02:58 PM
The lives taken weren't all that innocent. They got into a vehicle with a guy who was clearly drunk. I'm sure they had been drinking too, or they wouldn't have made that decision; "innocent" they weren't.
Posted by: Janice Location: Sun Prairie on Sep 24, 2008 at 11:15 AM
I see the family of a woman killed in a helicopter crash is suing the estate of the pilot. hopefully this little murderer's estate gets sued too! he doesn't have much, being that young, but what he has should go to the other families to pay for the funerals they had to pay for, because of his negligent, and reckless behavior! As a good lesson to all the other kiddies out there, keep in mind, when you die like this, your family is put through your hell too. I am OK with that, but just don't forget it. I hope every time the Putz family thinks of him, they remember he was a murderer, he took two innocent lives that weren't his to take! I hope that haunts the Putz family until their dying days.
Posted by: d on Sep 24, 2008 at 09:32 AM
Surprise, Another drinking and driving!!!
Posted by: sally Location: madison on Sep 24, 2008 at 07:29 AM
speaking of people dying in vehicle related accidents that involve people under 30, and alcohol, what was the finding on that accident back at the end of July that killed that guy from mineral point? Haven't heard from that crowd about how people just make mistakes. Any chance you can update us on that case, NBC15? be interesting to see if that accident was alcohol related too, especially since July was the safest month on record since 1946 or something!
Posted by: Shannon Location: Monona on Sep 24, 2008 at 07:18 AM
how sad that another drunk driver viciously destroyed two other lives, and why? because he thought he was a smarter person than the police? the lawmakers? the traffic engineers? because he just thought he was better than everybody and laws just didn't apply to him? I have always said, since the early 1980s, that there is hopefully a special place in heaven for those taken by drunk drivers, and there is a special place in hell, filled with pain, suffering, and misery, for anyone who kills another person by drunk driving. it is so preventable, call a cab. especially if you live in dane county! so sad, two good kids, and one killer.
Posted by: Judge..less ye Location: Anywhere on Sep 23, 2008 at 05:00 PM
Nicole - you were giving your friend the benefit of doubt that he did no wrong. There is nothing wromg with that. Unfortunatley he was over the legal limit. Unfortunatley his two friends made the choice to ride with him. Today's law would find him guilty. In today's society we are not forgiving. That a family should suffer from the mistakes of a son along with his death will be man's punishment to Richard n his family. Smitty's comments are testement. That two others also gone so young... When you pick a flower which do you pick the wilted or the best - God picked the best. No .. man is not forgiving. Thank God - that HE is. My heart n prayers go out to ALL three families.
Posted by: Well? on Sep 23, 2008 at 02:19 PM
Come on perfect Nicole, what do you have to say now? We're waiting....... I can't imagine anyone was surprised that alcohol was involved.
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 23, 2008 at 01:36 PM
i'm guessin C that they were holding that information... not that they just got the results back
Posted by: C Location: Madison on Sep 23, 2008 at 12:22 PM
I knew it was alcohol related right from the get go, I mean, I guessed, but I guessed right. What is weird is how long it took to figure that out, I mean how difficult is it to grab a bit of blood and run a test on it. Sounds fishy to me..
Posted by: josh Location: madison on Sep 23, 2008 at 12:18 PM
While I feel for all the families that have lost their loved ones, I feel no remorse for any of the 3 in the car. They knew he was drunk, they knew he should not have been driving. Too bad for them! Nicole, you are living in a dream world and I have to side with smitty on this one. You throw out the "I bet you never" crap is just that... crap! What he did was just what smitty said, he committed murder by use of a vehicle, nothing more, nothing less. Sure, almost everyone has done things they are not proud of, but that is not a line of defense. I have made plenty of mistakes in my life, but as smitty, I have never killed anyone. So stop trying to cover for this person as he has taken the life of two people (who's loved ones I am sure are not going to defend this person as much as you have)! Accident, maybe, but the fact still remains HE KILLED TWO PEOPLE while driving drunk! People who try to defend these people are the reason we are in the situation we are!
Posted by: nicoleisamoron on Sep 23, 2008 at 11:32 AM
Who would have guessed another drunk driver. nicole your are a moron at the least. RIP to all of them. This now makes at least 6 people die on that road in last 5 years.
Posted by: Smith Location: Madison on Sep 22, 2008 at 10:06 PM
BAC of .144. Cause of death = drunk driving.
Posted by: Jenna Location: Madison on Sep 22, 2008 at 05:50 PM
stephanie- homicide by intoxicated use of a motor vehicle would be the charge, had he survived, and who commits homicides? murderers! homicidal maniacs. killers. anti social deviants with deadly and violent tendancies. so, to sum it up for you stephanie, you live in a society where you worship murderers, you, personally, worship a murderer, and criticize anyone who uses language, terms, labels, identifications that you don't like. hope you enjoy whatever new society you decide to move to, because he commited homicide by intoxicated use of a motor vehicle, murder by drunk driving! A prohibited level almost .15, nearly twice the legal limit, or half again the old legallimit, either way, he was drunk when he murdered those people!
Posted by: smitty Location: madison on Sep 22, 2008 at 05:25 PM
Nicole, did you catch the 5 PM news on Monday 9.22? Blood alcohol determined by autopsy to be .144! So, it was homicide by intoxicaed use of a motor vehicle! no deer, no meds, nope- he was drunk, he drove, he killed two people! Are your eyes OK? I mean, after your posting and reasoning just blew up in your face like that, I was just wondering! He was drunk, he killed someone, two someone's, guilty. he commited homicide, so he is a murderer. what were you saying about facts, and glass houses? no deer involved in that one nicole. maybe a turkey, like a wild turkey, or some mist, like canadian mist. That's OK, you don't have to apologize nicole, I know you probably wouldn't mean it anyway, but next rant, be sure you have ground to stand on before you rip someone else's postings. twit!
Posted by: smitty on Sep 20, 2008 at 10:30 PM
nicole on 9.15- whatever, chick. there was no deer. and, it doesn't matter- drunk drivers are arrested for reckless homicide every freaking day, homicide, the act of murder. intentional, unintentional, it is still homicide, still killing another person, depriving the basic environment necessary to maintian independent life support- he's guilty, he's a murderer. who the hell cares what I have, or have not, done in my past- I know one thing I haven't done- killed two people in my car, or killed anyone else in anyone else's car! so, get off your hypothetical soap box with all your accusations of my past behaviors, and face facts. he drove, he lost control, he rammed his car into a tree, two innocent people died because of him, he's a murderer. a killer. the perpertrator of homicide. the wielder of a 2 ton weapon of death. get that part straight Nicole- no matter what you, your mother, or I did, we didn't kill those two innocent students, he did. and he is a freaking scumbag loser.
Posted by: stacey Location: madison on Sep 20, 2008 at 10:08 PM
how strange. no word on the cause of the accident yet.
Posted by: Nicole on Sep 15, 2008 at 11:38 AM
Ok Smitty, and I am sure from your ridiculous posts that you are a law abiding citizen at ALL times, right? YOU have never had a ticket, you always drive under the speed limit, have NEVER gotten behind the wheel of a car when you are tired, taking medication, had a glass of wine, etc...? You are lying if you say no! So, let's say as a for instance, a deer ran out into the road. Rick swerved to avoid hitting the deer. How are you going to call him a murderer for that?? You sound pretty self rightious for someone who DOESN'T KNOW THE FACTS!! Remember, those who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones!!
Posted by: Smitty Location: Madison on Sep 11, 2008 at 06:07 PM
Nicole- it doesn't matter what the cause, vehicle malfunction, UFO, spontaneous projectile vomiting of toenail clippings of aligators- whatever the "indirect" reasons, he lost control of the car. if you can't control the car, you're responsible for whatever happens, just as you are when you control the car- and taking someone else's life, without their permission, is murder, no matter how you try to disguise it, excuse it, or pretend it just ain't so. "Haters"? I don't hate him, or anyone else. I just think he is a murdering idiot that killed two people that trusted him to know what the hell he was doing, and able to control the vehicle he was operating! You're right about one thing Nicole, I am going to laugh my ass off when it come to light he was drunk off his ass when the collision happened! toxicology and reconstruction will tell the truth about this murderer's last moments on earth!
Posted by: Teddy Cleaver on Sep 11, 2008 at 02:42 PM
It is not an "accident" to hit a tree so hard that the tree ends up halfway through the car. It is a crash, caused by a decision, such as speeding. There is nothing accidental about it.
Posted by: Nicole Location: Milwaukee on Sep 11, 2008 at 08:43 AM
Smitty, what a fool you are! I am sure "Buddy" as you put it- "decided" to die at the scene! Just what he wanted to do! Murder?? Come ON! It's not like he forced his girlfriend, and a good buddy into his car, and planned to go out & get them all killed! This was an ACCIDENT... it could have been a deer, it could have been another oncoming car, it could have been vehicle malfunction- it could have been anything! To you and all the other "haters" out there that want to assume the worst, I hope you are eating your words if the true cause is ever released!
Posted by: Anon on Sep 10, 2008 at 10:16 AM
Who was driving the car anyway does anyone know for sure?
Posted by: Rick Location: Madison on Sep 9, 2008 at 10:35 PM
JJ- so what's your point? people should be allowed to carry weapons of peace and protection! thanks for backing the anti-gun regulation party- be sure to vote yes on conceal and carry laws passage next chance you get! and don't forget to check yes for the death penalty too! Thanks buddy- what a guy!
Posted by: Rebekka on Sep 9, 2008 at 05:41 PM
JJ what is so hard for you and everyone else to get about this part of the site? It is a place to COMMENT ON THE NEWS. It is NOT primarily a place to show support and sympathy.
Posted by: Smitty Location: wherever on Sep 9, 2008 at 03:45 PM
yep, buddy sure did a good job- killed himself at the scene of the accident, but left his friends alive so they could make it to the hospital- guess he wanted to make sure he wouldn't get sued if they lived through it. sure would like to see what the police found, like how long the skid marks were, or if he just slammed right into the tree- either way, he lost control of his vehicle he was driving, and killed two people he was directly responsible to keep safe from harm- if you kill someone, or cause their death by an action you perform, it is a murder, it may be unintentional homicide, but it is still homicide- just like homicide by drunk driving, which this may or may not be. either way, he caused the homicide of two people by his driving.
Posted by: Susan on Sep 9, 2008 at 11:39 AM
Josh, we all have the right to comment regardless of any choice we've made in our lives. I'm amazed at how this always comes up in these pages - that no one is allowed to comment unless they have never ever ever done anything "wrong" or made a mistake in their lives. Josh, I'm glad you're in that category but the rest of us are still allowed free speech.
Posted by: JJ Location: McF on Sep 9, 2008 at 11:18 AM
Rebekkah hahaha, first of all, over 225 years ago this rule called the first amendment was written to allow citizens to speak freely about the government without repercussions... Free speech doesn't mean saying what you want, when you want cuz you can.. by your logic, if someone gets pulled over and has a concealed weapon, they should not be convicted because they "have the right to bear arms" as for the families and friends, I know what its like to lose a friend to a car accident, its tough, but showing support is all the friends and families need right now. I hope everyone the best, and I send my deepest sympothies.
Posted by: Jane Location: Madison on Sep 9, 2008 at 10:54 AM
"My concerns are, why haven't we heard an explanation for a cause of the crash after all this time? " I agree. I can't think of another incident of this magnitude that went for so long without any updates as to cause, who was the driver, etc.
Posted by: Josh Location: Madison on Sep 8, 2008 at 10:21 PM
I feel for all the families and friends of the victims especially since they seemed to good, thoughtful, and productive people who would make this world a better place. My concerns are, why haven't we heard an explanation for a cause of the crash after all this time? All I've heard is speculation and no answers. Without answers we have people calling other people murderers and proclaiming that these students were seedy characters of the night which is darn right disrespectful. We've all made poor choices(like someone said earlier) and if you don't think you have, you might want to ask around your circle of friends. There is certainly a difference between speeding and murdering.
Posted by: Julia on Sep 4, 2008 at 05:00 PM
Kori never good to assume - I lost a "friend" who happened to be my nephew. As well, I have already lost two of my siblings and my father. I have my AARP card if that helps you on the age topic.
Posted by: Nicole Location: Milwaukee on Sep 2, 2008 at 04:23 PM
To: poster: Stacey, on Aug 28 - Where are you getting your information on the various tickets, owi, etc, that your reference that these kids have gotten?? I found none of that information on CCAP... Just a few "minor" infractions. Please be certain to make sure your info is accurate before you go trashing the names of these kids! My condolences to the families, who have lost young, forward thinking children who had much to offer this world! Everyone here that has something bad to say, or wishes to jump to the worst possible scenario for why this horrible tragedy happened should know IT DOESN'T DEFINE WHO THESE KIDS WERE. Special prayers go to the Hernandez-Putze family, while they grieve Rick.
Posted by: Kori on Sep 1, 2008 at 02:48 AM
Julia- I'm assuming I am a bit older than you, by the statements you are making (I don't have any college aged friends, but my oldest son does)- I was one of the "lucky" people who lost an uncle, and his son (my cousin" during the 9/11 attacks on New York, and my sister died during Katrina. while I am not saying your pain is any less than mine, I do believe that losing a sister you have known your entire life is a bit more traumatic than losing a "friend". My point being Julia, I do know pain, and will know more pain yet as life progresses and my own parents age, relatives work in dangerous occupations, and life's little fickle surprises like car accidents possibly claim even more- but thank you for your expression of kindness- I hope you never feel the pain of losing a family member, instead of just a "friend". God bless you too Julia, may peace be your dream tonight.
Posted by: Rebekkah on Aug 31, 2008 at 07:30 PM
Speculating about alcohol use when 3 young people drive into a tree isn't "abuse". If family members are caused more pain by reading these comments then they have a choice; don't read them. Until we see that the rules state "all comments must show compassion for everyone readig them" I think we are all allowed our first amendment rights.
Posted by: Kristine Location: Riverside, CA on Aug 31, 2008 at 04:41 AM
Richard, you were my son Brandon's best friend. You were an awesome person and our family will love and miss you a lot. You were a master chef, a fantastic swimmer and one of the brightest students I've ever met. You had so many swim metals on your jacket, there was barely room for anything else. I was proud of you and for your accomplishments. You were the greatest friend that Brandon ever had--You were his BEST friend.I had often wished that you were MY son. The world will be missing all of the contributions that you had to offer. You will be missed. We love you Richard and know that you are in heaven where you belong. I will pray for your family as I know you meant a lot to them. Until we meet again in Heaven, Goodbye my "son".
Posted by: Julia Location: Delafield on Aug 30, 2008 at 10:47 AM
Sorry Kori, just a plea from a friend and relative of the deceased for kindness and consideration. I hope you never have to witness much pain in your life. God Bless You.
Posted by: Michelle Location: Waunakee on Aug 30, 2008 at 09:38 AM
I think that the reason for the accident (whatever it is) matters only for the other students at the UW to remember to be careful themselves, for the road to be leveled if that was the cause. As far as the blame game goes with all the comments, sensitivity would go a long way for some of you. A discussion forum shouldn't be a forum to abuse people with your words. Be careful what you say because you can really cause so much more pain than the loss of 3 beautiful young people has already caused.
Posted by: Kori Location: Middleton on Aug 30, 2008 at 02:35 AM
Julia, sorry, can't have it both ways! 1st, you are judging us for judging others, (circular logic) so by saying we are guilty of not being nice, you are judging us! (nice try though! give you points for quotes & stuff!) 2nd- even if judging is done by people of pride, and pride being a sin & all, didn't God give his only son Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of our sins? Soooo- if our sins are to be forgiven, through the blood of Christ, where does the judgement part come in again as being the all terrible eternity in Hell problem that you seem to be judging us guilty of, worrying about our souls- b/c aren't then you judging God for being one to judge other people?Also, what John said wasn't very nice either, and he is one of the dead kid's brothers- so he should not judge the comments people are making or say what he said? Lastly, isn't it true that man does not know the will of God, so how do you know again, exactly, that we are to be judged? sounds prideful & that's a sin of pride!
Posted by: Rachel Location: Madison on Aug 30, 2008 at 01:50 AM
Um... Bill, so how then do you explain "Reckless (or unintentional) Homicide"? Not all homicides are "pre-meditated", and while I agree that "murderer" is a little harsh, the point is valid no matter how disturbing to us- by failing to control the motor veh, a person legally tasked, charged, and expected to protect the lives of anyone within that vehicle while it was in operation (not motion, operation) has failed those tasks & duties, thereby resulting in the reckless, unintentional termination of another person's life. sad, but reckless homicide is still homicide, whether they meant to or not.
Posted by: Tom Location: Madison on Aug 29, 2008 at 09:21 PM
Rick, Lindsey, and Dan I can't imagine that you're gone. I keep listening to "Let It Be" by the Beatles, hoping it will do something to help me deal with this, but I still can't imagine that I'll never see you again. I just have to remember all the times we smiled and laughed together. I pray there is a better place, and that you are there. Love, Tom
Posted by: Julia Location: Delafield, WI on Aug 29, 2008 at 05:21 PM
Judge not, lest ye be judged. For with what judgment ye judge, ye shall be judged: and with what measure ye mete, it shall be measured to you again. Even when we have the final investigation results, I'm fairly sure that no one person writing in this blog site is perfect. The big man upstairs is the chief judge. My mother always told me, if you can't say anything nice, don't say it at all. Maybe we should all take her advice.
Posted by: Bill Location: Madison on Aug 29, 2008 at 01:03 PM
I cried when I read this article. But the comments - wow! Murderer??? Definition: a criminal who commits homicide (performs the unlawful premeditated killing). Shame to the person that wrote that. The internet has never been the most mature of places but increasingly it seems that individuals offer immaturely presented negative remarks, observation, or criticism which then inflames others. The murderer comment can fall into this category because it can be perceived as a vicious attack on the driver. My UW degree is criminology and we were taught there is more benefit to maturely presenting opinions or criticism then to just label someone I do cheer Stephanie's passion and encourage her to channel it to promoting the safety message to the UW community.
Posted by: Barb Location: Dane County on Aug 29, 2008 at 01:01 PM
Has anyone heard of any news regarding the investigation or autopsy reports? Let us not judge until we get the full story. My prayers certainly go out the all three families. God Bless.
Posted by: stacey on Aug 28, 2008 at 08:08 PM
stephanie: people are stupid for drinking and driving; however, no one is saying that richard, dan or lindsey "got what they deserved" as you stated in one of your responses. people are just wondering out loud why and how this happened; which is a very typical and common response to tragedy. regardless of whether or not alcohol was a factor, you are right, they are gone and that stinks. your pain, as well as the pain of all the family and friends involved, is very real and very raw. loss of loved ones is always painful, no matter what the circumstances. at the risk of sounding disresctful, get some counseling. you have endured a lot and it can truly help. and yes, i speak from experience from having just lost my mom to cancer and a friend in a motorcycle accident (because he wasn't wearing a helmet...i am mad at him and hate him...but still love and miss him dearly). bless you.
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 28, 2008 at 05:50 PM
a friend of mine was passed on Midvale heading northbound by a car going "about 100 mph" 10 minutes before this accident occurred, and then passed the accident scene... While 100 mph is probably a bit of an exaggeration by someone who was incredibly shaken up because she could have easily been involved in this accident, people, please slow down! I am so sad that these 3 young people died, but also happy that no other cars were involved...
Posted by: Susan on Aug 28, 2008 at 05:26 PM
At the risk of having my head bitten off, I'm reminding everyone that this is a public forum for commenting on current news and the issues surrounding the news. It is NOT a memorial page for the deceased. So if someone wants to discuss drunk driving, excessive speed, road hazards, or any other related topic, they are allowed to do so without families/friends/unrelated people cutting down their comments.
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 28, 2008 at 02:18 PM
Gee, I hope this is not going to be the start of a very terrible school year. Thats rediculous.
Posted by: Di Location: Madison, WI on Aug 28, 2008 at 01:44 PM
My deepest sympathy to all who knew and loved these three young people. What a terrible tragedy. Until you lose a loved one in an accident, you'll not know how it turns your life upside down, forever!
Posted by: Anonymous Location: Madison on Aug 28, 2008 at 01:07 PM
I agree, Stephanie that this is a sad situation, but this is a forum where people can discuss these issues openly. Of course people are going to post their opinions, there’s no way around it. If you are “disgusted” by what you see here then don’t read it. The fact is, this was a very violent single car accident that happened at bar time, so most people are going to jump to conclusions about alcohol (just as I did). Also something of note, this vehicle was called into police as driving recklessly just minutes before the crash. But I guess we can’t talk about that.
Posted by: Anonymous Location: Madison WI on Aug 28, 2008 at 12:46 PM
Although i have never lost a child,i lost my 27 year old brother to a accident earlier this year i know the pain that the family is going through i have been there, and felt it first hand. I would not wish it upon anyone. The cirumstances do not matter at all, the end result is the same. My heart goes out to the family in this time of need. You all are in my prayers and thoughts.
Posted by: M Location: Madison on Aug 28, 2008 at 12:15 PM
It is so sad that these 3 young people died when they had so much promise and future ahead of them. We don't know if alcohol played a part or not yet, but remember, the university offers "Safe Ride" - a service where you get 4 free cab rides a month at night, so long as you are a current student. If you are tired or drunk or buzzed, call a cab!
Posted by: stephanie on Aug 28, 2008 at 11:25 AM
in regards to Jenna 8/27 as well i hope to god i never meet you. how dare you call someone you don't know a murderer. That was my brothers best friend, and a friend of mine. You disgust me and its a shame you are a part of this society. I am ashamed to be living in the same country as you. When something like this happens to a loved one of yours, i hope you look back on this and realize how ignorant you sound.
Posted by: stephanie on Aug 28, 2008 at 11:19 AM
it disgusts me the way people can care more about what caused the accident and not the fact that 3 families have to bury a loved one. first of all, last year at this time my brother was involved in an early morning accident. While i'm trying to grieve and cope with the fact that my brother is in a coma, people start contemplating whether or not alcohol was involved. Well guess what, no matter what caused the accident i still could not look into my brothers eyes and hear his voice, not knowing if i ever would again. Now this happens to richard, lindsey and dan. Richard was my brothers best friend, and i was with the 2 of them the night before this happened. If you are so brave to sit on this website and talk about how people are so stupid if they drink and drive, i want you to look mrs.putze in the eyes, see her pain, and tell her her son got what he deserved. youre a sick human being and until this happens to your family you wont understand the pain. RIP richard lindsey and dan
Posted by: Beth Location: Madison on Aug 28, 2008 at 10:57 AM
Jenna 8/27 11:32 Your "Murderer" rant is probably one of the most ridiculous, cold and STUPID things I have ever read..sigh My heart aches for all three and MOST of us can probably look back at something we did in our youth that was irresponsible but BY the GRACE of GOD or WHATEVER we weren't killed or we didn't kill someone else..........
Posted by: Melissa on Aug 28, 2008 at 08:55 AM
My sincerest condolences to all the families and friends. Patti and John, you are in my thoughts and prayers.
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 28, 2008 at 08:54 AM
My heart goes out to the families of these three young people during this extremely trying time. I pray that God will ease some of the suffering these families are going through. I personally know the mother of one of these children, and I have to write that I am so deeply disturbed that people would be so callous as to write such horrible things about any of these kids during this painful time. Before you write something, please remember that the families and friends of these students could be reading this. Understand that no matter what the situation was or is, there is nothing that can bring these people back and the pain the families and friends are feeling will only be heightened by the some of the insensitive things that have been written here.
Posted by: stacey on Aug 28, 2008 at 08:43 AM
having been an alcohol and drug counselor for many years now, i cannot help but "jump to the conclusion" that alcohol (or some other drug) was a factor; i know that is not fair, and i mean no disrespect, however, 9 times out of 10, certain circumstances and factors win out in the end; and this accident unfortunately parallels many other similar situations in which alcohol was involved. also,look at the victims legal history (one of the victims just received an owi in july; two have several speeding tickets; another has several tickets for failure to wear a seat belt and some have various other traffic violations...) 20- year-olds still think they are invincible, that nothing bad can happen to them. i don't think that will ever change. my thoughts and prayers do go out to all the family member and friends who lost loved ones. my the good memories and love and support of others carry you through a very rough road ahead.
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 28, 2008 at 06:41 AM
Oh how sad. It just goes to prove that children are on loan to us from God. I heard of a family which set up a scholarship fund in the name of their daughter who was killed just before classes in the law school started. Perhaps something like that could be started for these three.
Posted by: Ali Location: Stoughton on Aug 28, 2008 at 01:01 AM
Lindsey had been a friend of mine since middle school, though we drifted apart after we went to college. My heart aches with the loss of life of young people recently-personally, first Peter Talen in November and now Lindsey. My heart goes out to the friends and family of all three victims. Many people are sharing in this pain.
Posted by: Anonymous Location: central WI on Aug 28, 2008 at 12:31 AM
Madison sure should not have to level the road so cars can speed...maybe add some speed bumps so they have to slow down. Or maybe apply for a federal grant so Madison can study the matter...and then do nothing.
Posted by: Jenna Location: UW madison on Aug 27, 2008 at 11:32 PM
what a terrible epidemic we seem to be having these days, or perhaps it is a darwinian mutation in effect- a 20 something motorcycle driver dies from speed, on a curve, and hits a horse. these three 20 somethings, obviously (yes, I have lived in Madison all my life, have driven that road, know exactly where it happened) going too fast for the road they were on, and hit a tree. what is truly, deeply, heart wrenchingly sad is the fact that there is nothing that can be done once they get their licenses- they drive how they drive, and now someone driving a car is a double murderer for taking the life of two passengers in their car- thoughtless, irresponsible, heartless, murder. how sad it happened, but perhaps a blessing that at least a murderer isn't driving around campus this semester with all the pedestrian traffic getting to and from classes. how sad.
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 11:18 PM
steve if you don't have anything nice to say... just shut the _ up
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 10:21 PM
Wow! I'm so sorry to the families for your loss! It's eye opening especially since I travel Midvale Blvd every so often, I never even thought it to be that dangerous but obviously under the "right" conditions anything can happen! Again I'm so sorry for your loss!
Posted by: Jackie on Aug 27, 2008 at 08:08 PM
Patti and John my thoughts are prayers are with you at this devastating time. May God comfort you.
Posted by: Amy on Aug 27, 2008 at 07:46 PM
just now heard this--how sad, i am not sure where this took place on Midvale, but it must be a tricky spot. I just wish everyone could slow down. My sympathy to all the family and friends. God Bless
Posted by: Anonymous Location: green County on Aug 27, 2008 at 07:31 PM
This is ver sad. They haven't said if alcohol was involved. Maybe they were in a hurry to get home and driving too fast and lost control!No matter what 3 young lives were taken.My heart goes out to their families!
Posted by: Steph on Aug 27, 2008 at 06:53 PM
The families of these people are in my thoughts and prayers
Posted by: Connie Location: sharon ,wi on Aug 27, 2008 at 06:49 PM
Dear Daniel, My heart and condolenses firstly to all 3 families.....2ndly, Daniel you will be very missed and you were very loved. I hope the Angels Love your Music..your talent was so wonderful...RIP Dan..the Pattens in Sharon
Posted by: Cindy Location: Blue Mounds on Aug 27, 2008 at 06:08 PM
I am saddened by these senseless deaths, and the fact that these young adults were more than likely under the influence and speeding. Now their families are left to grieve, and those with promising futures are no longer here. When will people learn, and how many have to die, before people realize you do not drink and drive or get into a vehicle with someone who has. Tragic and preventable.
Posted by: Bitter Location: Madison on Aug 27, 2008 at 04:48 PM
Midvale Blvd is well-paved, very wide, and posted with a 30 mph limit. Except for presence of fresh snow or ice, it is perfectly safe at that speed, or under. It is also a residential road, NOT a freeway or high speed bypass. I have also seen countless accidents along its entire length over the years, and with the exception of the obvious winter-related ones, they are primarily the result people driving at speeds considerably over the posted limits (with and without alcohol's extra influence). Rather than modify the road, the city should consider actually enforcing the existing traffic laws on Midvale, consistently and for a prolonged period; at least until people get it into their heads to drive, if not sensibly, at least at a speed that won't kill them and/or others. We should not be bubble-wrapping the whole world because people can't restrain themselves or moderate their behavior.
Posted by: jen26 Location: madison on Aug 27, 2008 at 04:36 PM
I was on my way home from work 20 minutes after it happened. I knew by the looks of the tree that if anyone survuved it would be a miracle. My thoughts and prayers are with all families involved.
Posted by: Anonymous Location: Oregon on Aug 27, 2008 at 04:34 PM
My deepest sympathies to the family and friends of those involved. This is another terrible example of what can happen on the roads. Let's all just try to slow down and think of the weapon we are in when we drive!
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 04:29 PM
If others learn from their mistakes, they have not died for nothing. Please don't drink and drive! Its not worth it. My thoughts and prayers go out to all their family and friends.
Posted by: Anon on Aug 27, 2008 at 04:23 PM
I'm sorry to the friends and families of these students. I only wish that people would learn before it's too late.
Posted by: Debbie Location: Milwaukee on Aug 27, 2008 at 04:21 PM
My heart goes out to Patti, Rick's mom. It is a mother's nightmare to lose one of her children. My sympathies to all the families.
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 04:20 PM
It does not say that Alcohol was a factor in this case. They are still investigating that. Please don't jump to conclusions.
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 04:06 PM
Steve, this isn't the time to jump to conclusions or cast blame. Three families just lost their children and a countless others have lost their friends. Think before you type. RIP Lindsey, Richard, and Daniel... you will be missed.
Posted by: Anonymous Location: Milwaukee on Aug 27, 2008 at 04:03 PM
The Putze family is in our thoughts and prayers
Posted by: Sam Location: Lodi on Aug 27, 2008 at 04:03 PM
If the cause of this accident is the road, every road in Dane County will have to be replaced !! Why do accidents happen on straight roads ? The answer is Drunk Driving and high rates of Speed !!. I feel sorry for the Parents and there loss of there loved ones.
Posted by: Jackie on Aug 27, 2008 at 03:53 PM
The Myers family is in our thoughts and prayers.
Posted by: Steve Location: Madison on Aug 27, 2008 at 03:40 PM
Oh the wonderul things that happen because of alcohol. When will people ever learn??
Posted by: Anonymous Location: Madison on Aug 27, 2008 at 03:40 PM
Being in law enforcement, I know that this particular stretch of Midvale Blvd is very dangerous at high speeds. The northbound lane has a hump to it just north of Mineral Pont Rd, and if you are traveling at very high speeds it is enough to spin you out of control. Several fatal accidents have occurred in the same spot over the years. Very sad. Maybe the City of Madison should consider leveling that area off.
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 03:35 PM
So very sad. My thoughts go out to all the friends and family of the students lost.
Posted by: Tina Location: Madison on Aug 27, 2008 at 03:30 PM
to all the families involved -- my most heartfelt condolences ... as the mom of two kids this age, I have to say this -- do not drink and drive! do not drive too fast!!! the road is not deadly, too many drivers are ... we have lost too many wonderful, promising young people
Posted by: josh Location: madison on Aug 27, 2008 at 03:29 PM
While I agree it is the impact that kills, one would think that the two can be linked together. I mean, if you are belted in, and going 25 mph, I would find it hard to believe someone would have been injured enough to cause death. But strager things have happened. I was meaning no disrespect at all. If I offended you, for that I'm sorry.
Posted by: Lilianne Location: Stoughton on Aug 27, 2008 at 02:36 PM
RIP Lindsey, I will miss you very much. You had such a wonderful personality. My sorrow goes to all who had the pleasure to know her and the other victims.
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 02:35 PM
Richard was my brother. This is so hard to believe, but now he is gone forever. I love you Rick
Posted by: Anonymous Location: formally stoughton resident on Aug 27, 2008 at 01:57 PM
i know lindsey. she was only a few yrs ahead of me in school. my prayers go out to the family and friends. this is a tragic loss for anyone. josh-madison, speed doesnt nesecessarly kill its the impact that kills.
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 01:37 PM
how sad. that is a deadly road. i know of a few people that died on midvale blvd in last 5 years. rip and sympathy to friends and family.
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 12:57 PM
I only knew the girl...Hadn't met her boyfriend. She is originally from Stoughton. Not sure about the other two. I do not want to say a last name incase some family has not heard yet. At this point only close friends and family know.
Posted by: josh Location: madison on Aug 27, 2008 at 12:18 PM
They must have been traveleing at a pretty good rate of speed considering that two of them were belted in and at least one of the two died. My sympathy to the families!
Posted by: Ashley Location: Madison on Aug 27, 2008 at 11:56 AM
RIP Lindsey! You were a true unique spirit and I will miss your zest for life. *tear*
Posted by: Anonymous Location: Madison, WI on Aug 27, 2008 at 11:43 AM
I am in my early 20's and from Madison area, I have siblings & a lot of friends that party in Madison and sometimes are very irresponsible about it. I get so nervous when I hear these stories so if anyone has ANY info of who these victims are, it would be much appreciated! Thank you!!
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 11:12 AM
Lindsey you will be missed so much! RIP We love you.
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 10:43 AM
my prayers go out to the families
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 09:44 AM
RIP Lyndsey!
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 08:21 AM
RIP.