Debate on Primate Testing
Save Email Print
Debate on Primate Testing
UW-Madison played host to a major debate over an ethical dilemma in primate research and testing Monday night.
Font Size:

Posted Monday, March 15, 2010 --- 10:48 p.m.

UW-Madison played host to a major debate over an ethical dilemma in primate research and testing Monday night.

The school had to defend its stance on testing for different human ailments and illnesses.

One particular UW researcher participating focuses his research on developing therapies for eye diseases like glaucoma.

One point of debate keyed in on whether experimenting on animals will actually change the lifespan of humans.

"Well that doesn't make any sense to me at all," said Rick Bogle of the Alliance for Animals group. "You're going to die whenever you do and whatever progress we've made so far is still going to be there if we stop using animals, whether animals are the cause of that progress or not."

One UW scientist disagrees.

"To say that it wouldn't make any difference and, 'Well, you're going to die anyway, so what difference does it make?' I think is an incredibly, with all due respect, is an incredibly incorrect understanding of how medical research works," said Paul Kaufman, member of the UW Department of Ophthalmology.

The primate center at the UW is one of the largest in the country and has about 1,200 monkeys.

The center already has said most of the research it does is non-invasive.


Latest Comments

Posted by: Pete Location: Madison on Mar 18, 2010 at 01:06 PM

HIV POS, the argument is NOT "I don't want to test drugs and treatment on animals, therefore we shouldn't do it." The only reason I mentioned that I am willing to forgo treatment is to respond to accusations of hypocrisy, such as some that have occurred in earlier posts. The thrust of my argument is in the last two sentences in my earlier post. The central issue is that I do not think we are entitled to subject non-human primates to these experiments, just as we are not entitled to subject severely cognitively disabled humans to them. Obviously, I'm very sorry about your condition, and I also suffer from some severe health problems for which I want a cure. But I don't think we should experiment on disabled humans to find one, and I don't think there's a morally relevant difference between them and non-human primates.
Posted by: Patricia Location: Portage on Mar 17, 2010 at 09:58 PM

Animals are poor and inaccurate predicters of human physiology. Mice are different at the MOLECULAR level. Thalidomide was tested on animals with no ill effects, but produced dwarfed limbs in the babies of human mothers exposed to it. Simian aids is a different disease than human aids which monkeys do not manifest at all. All you have to do is be with a pet dog or cat for a little while to recognize their consciousness and love - often superior to our own. This pedestal that we have put our species on is not deserved. This arbitrary hierarchy is false. No other species is hoarding billions of animals purely for slaughter to give themselves heart disease and their planet climate failure. WE are destroying our oceans, massacring a record number of non-human species into extinction, sport hunting, trapping, incarcerating animals in labs to torture them. Homocentric arrogance is obscene. Humility and compassion will heal this world or we will destroy it all with our overpopulation
Posted by: HIV POS on Mar 17, 2010 at 02:27 PM

Well Pete while you are willing to forgo future advancements of medicine to treat and cure diseases, I am not. So who wins? I have HIV. I want a cure. Why should I not get one just because people like yourself dont want to test drugs and treatments on animals?
Weather Authority
Watch your local weather 24/7.
News Links
Looking for something you saw on NBC 15? Find it here.
Double Dollar Deals
Experience our area's best restaurants at a Half-Off price.
Golf Double Dollar Deals
Experience our area's best golf courses at a Half-Off price.
Family Double Dollar Deals
Experience our area's best businesses at a Half-Off price.
Perfect Home
Find out how to make your perfect home.
What's On?
Click here to see our program guide.
The Health Professional
Find answers to your health questions.
Crystal Apple Awards
Click Here to See the 2010 Crystal Apple Award Winners & Honorable Mentions!
AP Video