Army Advertising or Military Recruitment? Save Email Print
Reporter: Melissa Wollering
Email Address: mwollering@nbc15.com

A | A | A

The Army bought ad time on scoreboards at Madison schools. Now parents and students want a timeout. At Monday night's school board meeting a group of people asked the board to remove the ads.

Students and parents say the army ads that appear on gym and stadium scoreboards at four Madison high schools look like recruiting material. About fifty protesters rallied outside the Doyle Administration building before Monday night's meeting, then went inside to urge the board to take the ads down. The ads read "Are you Army Strong?" and have a phone number to call for information. The district has separate policies outlining rules for both military recruitment and advertising. MMSD Board President Arlene Silveira says the ads met those conditions but some are not so sure.

Former Madison East Guidance Couselor Dave Hoppe says he is shocked to hear that the army ads are a part of district revenue and says students should not be directly targeted by the military in their daily classes.

"All materials should be in the guidance counselor's office and how they can figure out that gyms and football fields are the guidance office is absolutely beyond me," says Hoppe.

Hoppe also cites a rule laid out in the district's military recruitment policy that designates all military information be posted in school guidance offices.

"We certainly don't want to have policies that conflict with each other," says Silveira. "Our interpretation at this point in time is that this would not truly qualify as recruiting materials."

A group of students is asking the district to make three changes in its recruiting policy in addition to removing the ads. Instead of having high school students opt-out, have them opt-in when asked if they wish to be contacted by military recruiters. Students also want recruiters removed from lunchrooms. They also want to close what they call loopholes in the three-visits-per-year rule.

The topic was not on the board's agenda. So while members heard testimony from about 45 people, they cannot make any decisions unless they take it up at a future meeting.

More Stories
Body, Vehicle Found in River

GRAY TELEVISION GROUP, INC. LEGAL TERMS FOR WEBSITE USAGE

Fire Damages McDonald's Restaurant

Carbon Monoxide Deaths: Mother Sues

AWOL Inmate

Sex Offender Missing

Nativity Lawsuit Dismissed

UPDATE: Hit and Run Investigation

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Tavis Location: Bismarck ND on Sep 26, 2008 at 03:17 PM
Oh but it is ok for coke to put an ad up. Hey great at least your kids can get fat on coke instead of maybe getting a future. Also it looked like recruiting ads noooo way what do you thing all ads are do you think Walmart just wants you to stop and say hi. Pull your collective heads from you know where.

Posted by: Katie Location: Portage on Nov 8, 2007 at 03:21 PM
I am sadend by the fact that parents are making such a big deal about this. If your child wants to find out about the military they will, and if they want to join they will, just because its on a scoreboard does not mean that they will run out and join right away. Its on tv commercials, all over the news and talked about everywhere. Be proud of the military not shamefully selective about hiding the fact that the brave and strong join the military. Its too bad that some parents are so overly protective of their children that they would rather just say that they support it than actually support it. Get a life is all i have to say to those people who are hypocrits about the military!!!....PROUD MILITARY SPOUCE AND SUPPORTER OF THE USA MILITARY!!!!

Posted by: Rosa Location: Madison on Nov 6, 2007 at 08:43 AM
The Army is doing their Adverticing under the first Amendment right, and i am sure that they (the Schools) are not doing this for free. The Schools are getting very well compensated. Let's stop all this bickering and start concentrating on our Kids Education. So if People want the Army to stop putting up the Boards etc, then what is the School going to do as far as the extra Income goes, since i am sure the extra Money does help them out quite a bit.

Posted by: MM Location: WV on Nov 6, 2007 at 08:15 AM
IIRC the opt-out policy wrt military recruiters is tied to a school's federal funding. So, if the school wants to change that policy it had best be prepared to lose that funding. Harvard University found this out the hard way in court, and caved when it realized it would lose $30 million in various federal grants if it tried to change its policies.

AP Video