UPDATE: County Denies Claims in Crandon Shootings Save Email Print

A | A | A

UPDATE: Thursday, June 26, 2008 --- 2:50 p.m.

CRANDON, Wis. (AP) -- An attorney says Forest County has denied claims seeking millions of dollars for the families of young people fatally gunned down by an off-duty sheriff's deputy.

Charles Bohl said Wednesday the county took no action on the claims within 120 days, which means they were automatically denied under state law.

Bohl, an attorney for the county's liability insurance company, says the denial means the families can now file civil lawsuits if they desire.

The notices of claim alleged negligence by Tyler Peterson's employers contributed to the shooting rampage last October that killed six young people at a party in Crandon. Peterson later committed suicide.

The families' attorney did not immediately return a telephone message seeking comment.

(Copyright 2008 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)

______________________________________________________

Friday, May 30, 2008 --- 6:25 a.m.

MADISON, Wis. (AP) -- Newly released text messages between a 20-year-old sheriff's deputy and his on again, off again girlfriend show the angst he felt in the day before he killed her and five others in Crandon last fall.

The state Justice Department released text messages yesterday that show Tyler Peterson went on clinging to 18-year-old Jordanne Murray, even as she told him she needed time to sort out her feelings. He told her that his worst fear was losing her to someone else.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

UPDATED Thursday, May 8 --- 1:50pm

MADISON, Wis. (AP) -- The state Justice Department has released new documents confirming an off-duty deputy who killed six people shot himself as he fled police last fall.

Forest County Sheriff's Deputy Tyler Peterson gunned down six people with an assault rifle at a Crandon party last October.

Investigators say he shot himself in the head three times in the woods hours later as police closed in. Questions have swirled about how Peterson could have shot himself three times.

The Justice Department released a summary Thursday of Peterson's autopsy that showed only one of the shots damaged Peterson's brain. Soot rings were found around the entrance wounds, suggesting the shots were fired at close range.

Copyright 2008 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________

Updated Friday --- February 8, 2008 -- 8:50am

MADISON, Wis. (AP) -- The state Justice Department's final report on the fatal shootings in Crandon shows hints of violence in the gunman's past.

Tyler Peterson took the lives of his ex-girlfriend and five others before killing himself last October.

Charlie Neitzel was the only one who survived the shooting at a Crandon apartment. He told investigators Peterson had been violent since fifth grade, beating up his cousin and throwing rocks. Neitzel says Peterson controlled his then-girlfriend, Jordanne Murray, pushing her around, stalking and harassing her in the weeks before the shootings.

The state investigation shows Peterson ripped the cable connectors out of the TV after fighting with Murray on the night she kicked him out of her apartment. Murray's father, Paul, who lived upstairs, says Peterson was uncontrollable and that police had to come to the apartment to calm him down.

Murray once told her employer, restaurant owner Sue Palubicki, that Peterson pushed her down, wouldn't let her participate in a wedding and that she needed his permission to go bowling.

(Copyright 2008 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________

Updated Thursday --- February 7, 2008 -- 8:25pm

Tyler Peterson's last call

(AP) -- Here are excerpts from the transcript of Tyler Peterson's call to Forest County District Attorney Leon Stenz from a friend's cabin where Peterson holed up after killing six people in Crandon. Peterson killed himself minutes after the call ended.

------

Stenz: All right uh. You going to uh, let ... come into custody Tyler or -- what -- what do you need to talk to me about?

Peterson: It, it depends on the terms.

Stenz: All right. What would you like to know?

Peterson: Um ... All -- I guess I would like to see what kind of deal you would offer me first.

Stenz: What kind of deal in what respects?

Peterson: For ... charges.

Stenz: Well it's a little early at this point, Tyler. I don't even -- I'm just -- I'm just down here in Washington County. I don't even know what's happened so far. Uh ... an important thing at this point is that everybody gets safe and that you come into custody, we can work it out from there. Uh ---

Peterson: Well ... Leon. Everyone here is safe, they feel safe. I'll let you talk to anyone that's here.

...

Peterson: Leon, so what do you want? Leon?

Stenz: Tyler?

Peterson: Yea.

Stenz: Yea. You -- are you willing to give yourself up Tyler or?

Peterson: Yea --

Stenz: What do, what do you need?

Peterson: Conditions.

Stenz: Huh? What condition is that?

Peterson: Um. I'll keep the gun on me and it's not like I'm going to have it raised or anything like that -- I'm used to having a gun on me, and that's normal practice for me. Um, but ... I'm not going to go to Forest County.

Stenz: Yea. Well (sic) see -- You know, everybody makes, uh, bad decisions, Tyler. It's time to make the good one. Here's -- You know what goes on with these things, you know, you -- you -- you have to do something for us, you got to give us the gun. We can't -- How are we going to take you into custody when you got a gun?

Peterson: Leon, you guys have an armored vehicle --

Stenz: Well, that's for your --

Peterson: A 40 --

Stenz: -- That's for your protection.

Peterson: A 40 caliber can't even ... touch the paint on that.

Stenz: I mean we, we're trying to protect you, Tyler. We don't want nothing to happen to you.

Peterson: I understand what you're saying. But, in the same sense, I really don't trust everyone that's involved here.

Stenz: All right, what --

Peterson: There's a few people on the county that I trust --

Stenz: Uh huh. Who's that?

Peterson: -- And I don't trust any federal agencies. DCI, FBI, whatever, whoever's involved in this, I have zero trust in them.

...

Stenz: All right. Tyler I got to -- what -- what are you suggesting then? Tell me what you think you'd feel comfortable with.

Peterson: Driving to Oneida County.

Stenz: Would you be willing to do that?

Peterson: With everyone here.

Stenz: Well. Why -- you know, that's -- makes it, you know, Tyler, do you think that's a good decision? What, what is your concern? Why, why do you need everybody with you?

Peterson: That's the way I feel comfortable and --

Stenz: Well what, what makes you feel uncomfortable about going in a squad car?

...

(The issue was never resolved before the call ended with Stenz saying he wanted Peterson to call him back. Moments later Peterson was dead.)

------

Source: Wisconsin Division of Criminal Investigation Case Report, Crandon Death Investigation.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Updated Thursday --- February 7, 2008 -- 8:20pm

Families react to end of shooting investigation

WAUSAU, Wis. (AP) -- The state's investigation into the Crandon shoots is closed, but it hasn't satisfied everyone who was close to the six young people gunned down by an off-duty sheriff's deputy last October.

Wayne Coulter is the live-in boyfriend of Jenny Stahl, whose 14-year-old daughter Lindsey died in the rampage.

He says he can't believe the official conclusion that the killer, 20-year-old Tyler Peterson, committed suicide by shooting himself three times in the head as police closed in on him in some woods.

Details from the state investigation were released Thursday, including the official version that a sniper wounded Peterson in the arm before he shot himself twice in the chin and then shot himself again in the side of the head.

AP

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Updated Thursday --- February 7, 2008 -- 12:00pm

Justice Department: Deputy committed suicide after killing 6

MADISON, Wis. -- Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen says no criminal charges will be brought as a result of anyone's interaction with Tyler Peterson from the time he killed 6 people in Crandon, injured another and then later took his own life.

Van Hollen released findings of the state investigation into the Crandon shooting Thursday.

He says Peterson, a sheriff's deputy, was wounded by a police sniper in the woods near a friend's house and then "apparently shot himself three times."

The lead state investigator, Bradley Kust, explained how Peterson could have shot himself in the head three times. He said in prepared remarks, that Peterson's first two shots entered his chin, but it was a third shot to the right side of his head that caused his death.

The DOJ's timeline says Peterson went to a house party in hopes of making up with ex-girlfriend Jordanne Murray during the early house of October 7th.

Asked to leave, Peterson got an assault rifle from his truck, went back inside and started shooting. He killed Murray and five of her friends. Another was injured but survived.

Peterson then fled to a friend's home. Hours later, he walked into woods where he was wounded in the left biceps by the sniper. The justice department's timeline says he then killed himself shortly after noon.

AP

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Posted Monday -- February 4, 2008

More families file claims in Crandon shootings

CRANDON, Wis. (AP) -- More families have filed claims seeking to hold the employers of a Forest County sheriff's deputy accountable for a shooting rampage that killed six young people and severely wounded another.

Forest County Clerk Ann Mihalko says 12 notices of claim were filed with her office Monday morning. The victims' estates and parents are seeking money from the county for their deaths.

Crandon City Attorney Lindsay Erickson says similar claims also were filed with the city. She says under state law, the local governments can either allow or disallow the claims.

Tyler Peterson, 20, gunned down six young people on Oct. 7 after he showed up at a house party in Crandon and was rebuffed in his attempts to make up with an ex-girlfriend.

Peterson was also a part-time Crandon police officer.

AP

Click Pictures to Enlarge
More Stories
Non-Profits Cutting Back

Lightning Strikes, Kills Watertown Boy

Flood Emergency: Standing Water Still Keeping People Out

FLOOD AFTERMATH: The Road Ahead

Antibiotics Warning: FDA Calls for Urgent Warning on Tendon Risks

Bones of Infant Found in Sauk County

Man Tentatively Charged with Robbery

Wis. Court Rules in Favor of Walgreens in Tax Case

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jun 27, 2008 at 09:34 AM
Hey Jamie at 8:25p.m.When you refer to how frustrating it is to get into a "police Department" due to the "psychological exam" why is that so bothersome to you? It is my opinion if you feel that way, maybe for the first time they are finding a nut before he gets into the department.

Posted by: Jamie Location: Madison on Jun 26, 2008 at 08:25 PM
You know this is getting frusturating to see that more people want to bring law suits against law enforcement. First it is the Marino case and now it is the Crandon case. I would like to ask the families what good is getting money out of these situations. It appears to me these families are using this as an opportunity to "milk the system." Which is bothersom. My heart goes out to the families who lost loved ones, but getting money is not going to bring them back! I can understand pressing the departments to change their policies to so that they can have a better response when situation occur like this in the future. But getting money is not the answer. I myself am going to law enforcement and I am witnessing how the hiring processes are changing across the state. Most departments now require a psychological examination, this is very frusturating for people who want to pursue a career in this profession. The families have done enough dont "milk the system."

Posted by: TIM on Jun 26, 2008 at 04:35 PM
Hey Anon 2:21p.m. If you really are a relative I want to give you my deepest sympathy. However, When things like this happen the people involved especially when it comes to law enforcement, and for what ever reason, when it comes to those people they are the ones who are in denial the most, and are not about to accept responsibility for anything. I have no idea why that is but they can at least get a backbone and start to aknowledge accountability. And there most certainly alot of that in many departments.

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Madison on May 31, 2008 at 02:21 AM
i am a 32 year old relative to the late Jordanne, and we all know this is sad but it is time to move on. whats done is done. if the good lord said it was time for ALL of these kids to go then it was time. law enforcement or not it was going to happen. yes many things can be done to change policy on hiring into the law enforcement and eventually something will be done, but please remember that small town folk are different than city goers and every law enforcement department has there own set of requirements for being an officer, every department has a hard time filling positions with the most capable officers and crandon was no different. it is not easy getting the top cops to come patrol some tiny town out in the middle of nowhere with no real super hero crime fighting to be done. everyone does the best they can with what they have. please move on. learn from and forgive those who do not need to be judged by anyone other than god.

Posted by: Reggie Location: Madison on May 30, 2008 at 04:10 PM
This is a tragic event that can happen at any place at any time! This guy was way to young to be a cop! This is why when you hire police they should be in their late 20's to late 30's! Far to much occurs in life betweent the ages of 18 and 25! I think if we make a practice of hiring people after they mature a bit it gives us a better look at what type of person they are! People are still very impressionable in their early 20's! Look at the Madison Police Departments new recruits! Many of them are far too young to be officers in my opinion! Yes they are old enough to serve our country so they should be old enough to serve our city but they are too young! I think if this young man was in a interview process at the age of 30 he would have not been hired because he would have probably messed up anyway in his life!

Posted by: mary Location: madison on May 30, 2008 at 01:53 PM
even if he wasn't in law enforcement, this still could have happened. what a tragedy.

Posted by: Anonymous on May 30, 2008 at 11:06 AM
wow i must of missed he shot himslef in the the head 3 times, makes u wonder.

Posted by: lisa Location: madison on May 30, 2008 at 09:32 AM
This has nothing to do with law enforcement. Yes, he had guns, he may have had guns anyway. This isn't about the police dept., it's about a dude with some serious issues that nobody spotted.

Posted by: G on May 30, 2008 at 09:24 AM
I think its funny how many people that have a need to control other people when things happen, they need other people with them to hold their hand. Tyler, after killing those other kids and he's on the phone with the D.A. he needs people to go with him, or he needs to carry his own firearm with him. What an insecure disgrace for a human.

Posted by: Tim on May 30, 2008 at 09:21 AM
Hey Gary, It is a known fact all law enforcement had to do was look into his record. He was considered a suspect in a sexual assault. That would mean if these morons had their brain engaged he would not have been considered for employment.

Posted by: Anonymous on May 30, 2008 at 09:13 AM
This is a national tragedy. The youth of America don't have good roll models and no one who supervises them. I believe that his picture should be above with the victims. They were perhaps as sick as he was.

Posted by: Gary Location: Jefferson on May 30, 2008 at 07:50 AM
If this "kid" would have been put through a mental competency test prior to his being hired, this may have never happened. Besides, is 20 a proper age for person to become an officer of the peace? What life experiences has he had to deal with the pressures of the job? Or even to deal with the vast differances of the public? I am starting to wonder if there should be an age requirement for jobs such as these. Now before everyone starts slamming me, I realize there are kids out there that are competant to hold a position of this caliber, but do not think the vast majority are really, honestly qualified. I do not have the answers, just a thought.

Posted by: Anonymous on May 8, 2008 at 03:39 PM
I think it speaks "beyond volumes" how Tyler Peterson who is in Law Enforcement would make a statement of that magnitude. "Theres a few people on the county that I trust,I don't trust any federal agencies, I have zero trust in them." Boy!!! Thats great!!! I hope J.B.,Ed wealon, and every other respected law enforcement MORON thinks about those words daily. THE KID HAS REASONS FOR FEELING THAT WAY!! LOL!!! HOW NEAT!! To the Survivor, I'm sending you my regards and hope you are healing well, nothing a person can say will help make a difference and NO ONE KNOWS WHAT YOU HAVE BEEN THROUGH, BEST WISHES!! ALWAYS!!!

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Madison on Feb 8, 2008 at 10:29 AM
This was a Tragedy, but noone could forsee this. Stop blameing Law Enforcement. It is Time for healing.

Click here for more information