Zimmermann Murder: 911 Investigation Save Email Print
Reporter: NBC15 News Team
Email Address:


A | A | A

UPDATE Posted Thursday, May 15 --- 5:30pm

The following is a memo sent to the Dane County Board of Supervisors, from Scott McDonell, Chairman:

"I want to let you all know about the next meeting I am scheduling in order to move forward with our review of the performance of the public safety communications center.

I plan to hold a meeting of the Executive Committee, open to all supervisors and the public, on June 4th at 6:00pm in Room 201. I anticipate that we will approve an independent audit of our 911 center at that meeting in order to review their performance with fresh eyes. Public testimony would also be taken at this meeting, as was done at the joint committee meeting on May 8th. As a reminder, we have had two opportunities for public comment to date: the May 8th joint meeting of Public Protection and Judiciary and the May 12th Personnel and Finance Committee.

We are working with the Association of Public Safety Communications Officials International, the professional association for public safety communications, to bring one of their staff here for the meeting to describe their Member Assistance Advisory Program. This program provides peer reviews of the operations of public safety communications centers, and has been used by a number of counties and municipalities to assess the performance of the 911 centers. We have also invited staff from the Waukesha County 911 Center, who had a review performed by APCO, to discuss their experience.

______________________________________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Wednesday, May 14 --- 11:50am

Press Release from Eileen Bruskewitz and Jack Martz:

Members of the Dane County Board will hold a public hearing this Monday, May 19th, from 6:00 – 8:00 p.m. at the Fitchburg Community Center, 5510 Lacy Road, (Lower Level) to hear public testimony relating to issues facing Dane County’s 911 system and center.

Members of the public are welcome to attend and testify at the hearing.

Dane County 911 Director Joe Norwick, Dane County Executive Kathleen Falk, Sheriff David Mahoney and Madison Police Chief Noble Wray have been invited to speak at the hearing and answer any questions as their time would allow.

Dane County Supervisors Ronn Ferrell (District 15) Eileen Bruskewitz (District 25) and Jack Martz (District 33) will co-chair the meeting. Time for speakers will be allotted based on an estimate of the likely number of speakers at the hearing so everyone has an opportunity to have their views considered.

“We feel is important for the public to hear the available facts regarding the 911 Center, it’s mission and staffing, as well as giving citizens their first opportunity to give us input regarding 911 in Dane County.”

The supervisors ask the public to bring any questions they may have about the 911 system. In addition, this hearing is an opportunity to let members of the 85 user groups of the 911 system tell the public about their interactions, both positive and negative, with the 911 Call Center.

The focus of the hearing will be the 911 Center’s performance and its future, and not on the specifics of the Brittany Zimmerman case that is still an active police investigation. If time does not allow all questions to be answered, the public will have the opportunity to give their questions to Supervisors so they may be asked at future meetings held by the County Board and various committees.

We are holding this hearing to allow the public to begin the process of regaining the trust it must have in our 911 system. We also hope to help educate the public about the 911 system so we’ll have the most effective one possible. The people of Dane County deserve nothing less.

______________________________________________________________________________________________

UPDATED Friday, May 9 --- 9:45pm

Madison Mayor Dave Cieslewicz toured 911 center tonight following a mishandled call from murder victim Brittany Zimmermann.

The tour was actually planned before the recent murders of Joel Marino and Brittany Zimmerman. The city's 20-year contract with the 911 center is up in July.

The mayor says he wants to get a better understanding of how the center works. "Specifics of how calls are handled, calls coming from cell phones," says Mayor Cieslewicz. "Of course, how those calls are handled both when we're able to make contact with and when there isn't sufficient information, how those are handled, how those are logged, how the operators can juggle those calls."

The Dane County 911 Center Director testified before the county board Thursday night.

Joe Norwick apologized to Zimmermann's family about the mistakes made the day the U-W student was killed in her Doty Street home. A dispatcher did not call Zimmermann's cell phone back after it disconnected, instead providing a call-back to a hang-up call.

County Board Chairman Scott McDonell: "Is this common to have multiple errors like this or is it uncommon?"

Norwick: "I don't think it's a frequent occurrence, I think people are human. People make mistakes. people in a very stressful job make mistakes."

Norwick says he can't guarantee that no mistakes will be made, but is working to limit the opportunities for mistakes.

Changes are already in the works to improve communication between different agencies in Dane County. NBC15 News has learned 30 million dollars will go toward replacing 911 computers and other equipment.

Meantime, County Board Chairman Scott McDonell says the board wants to bring in an outside source to review policies and procedures at the 911 center and make improvements.

"It seems the policies are solid, it's whether they are being followed or not. That's really a concern especially for someone like me who lives downtown, right in the middle of basically unsolved murders" said McDonell.

Board supervisors are also concerned about whether the 911 center followed a strategic plan from 2004. The report recommended increasing staffing, changing procedures and creating a stronger oversight board.

______________________________________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Thursday, May 8 -- 5:00pm

At 5:30 Thursday night, the director of Dane County's 911 center will be in the hot seat, trying to explain the botched 911 call from Brittany Zimmermann the day she was murdered.

Today, NBC 15s Carleen Wild learned:

- City and county officials are concerned too much information is being said in this case.

- The District Attorney, Chief of Police, two police captains and a detective working on the case walked together into the County Executive's office.

- They are very concerned about the statement the union steward has made about what is or isn't on the 911 tape, and essentially asked that nothing else be said by anyone - in regard to the call or what may be on the tape.

- There is concern that too much information if being released and will jeopardize not only the investigation, but also a possible genuine confession.

NBC 15s Carleen Wild also confirmed the following changes coming to Dane County 911:

- 30 million dollars has been authorized to spend to replace all 911 computers, radio towers, equipment and other technology that supports the 911 call center.

- The new software will better bridge what have been communication gaps between the 60 plus emergency response teams, meaning the different community police, fire and other agencies within Dane County, that have to interact when there is an emergency.

Stay with NBC 15 and www.nbc15.com for continuing coverage of this developing story.

______________________________________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Thursday, May 8 --- 8:05am

Today, Dane County 911 officials will brief Dane County Board members on the 911 investigation.

It takes place at 5:30pm at the City-County Building (210 Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd., Room 201).

The meeting is open to the public, but board members may go into closed session to discuss any personnel-related issues.

NBC15 News will have live reports from this meeting on NBC15 News at 5pm and 6pm, and a full report on NBC15.com and NBC15 News at 10pm.

______________________________________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Wednesday, May 7 -- 1:50 pm

Madison: Madison Police are saying today the 911 center's mistake did not derail or jeopardize the Zimmermann murder investigation.

Tuesday NBC 15 News reported the 911 center sent detectives down the wrong path initially, by saying a dispatcher had called back Brittany Zimmermann's cell phone and two men had answered and said there was no emergency.

In fact, the dispatcher never did call Zimmermann's cell phone, instead the two men were from a 911 hang up in the Town of Middleton.

But it took 13 days for the 911 center to catch the mistake. By then, police had "focused some investigative efforts on that callback and the two males".

Wednesday, a spokesman says they were investigating many leads early in the case and the two men were not the main focus of detectives, and this mistake did not "derail" the investigation.

The dispatcher that messed up the call has transferred to another job but could still face discipline.

Dane County Executive Kathleen Falk says she has no plans to discipline or fire Joe Norwick, the 911 center director.

But that doesn't mean she didn't have plenty of criticism for his performance in the last few days.

Joe Norwick has faced a lot of media pressure since last Thursday, when it was revealed one of his 911 center dispatchers failed to send police to help Brittany Zimmermann the day she was murdered.

At the time Norwick was brusque and unapologetic. "I don't think there's anything to apologize for at this time," he said.

Since then Dane County Executive Kathleen Falk has apologized for him. "I concluded that an apology was appropriate for the errors committed in our 911 center."

But it wasn't just his tone that brought criticism. Thursday, Norwick was asked if the dispatcher was still working in the 911 center.

Norwick said she had worked in the center after the screw up. But it was later revealed the dispatcher requested and received a transfer and is now in a different county department.

Falk was asked why Norwick mislead reporters. "He believes, when I asked him the same question, that he technically and honestly answered the questions he was asked. I said, 'Joe, while I understand you answered the questions technically accurate. The impression left by everyone in that room was different."

County Board Chairman Scott McDonell had similar worries. "It does concern me. I think that will be one of the issues we raise Thursday." Thursday is when Norwick will testify before county board supervisors.

McDonell says in private they've been getting better answers. "I know he has a long distinguished record. I just think the media part of it is not his strong suit, and it's unfortunate."

Despite all this Falk says Norwick won't be disciplined. "I have not agreed with a number of the statements...that Director Norwick has said in the last several days. But I have confidence in his ability to lead our 911 center."

Falk has called for an external investigation of the mistake. That will be conducted by the Association of Public Safety Communications Officials.

______________________________________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Wednesday, May 7 --- 9:00am

Just a clarification from the Middleton Police Department:
Recent news reports related to the Brittany Zimmermann case indicated that a landline 911 hang-up call that center personnel handled during the time period that is the focus of the investigation originated in "Middleton."

We would like to clarify that the call originated in the "Town of Middleton" not in the City of Middleton. Landline 911 calls originating in the City of Middleton are directed to the City of Middleton Communications Center, not the Dane County Communications Center.

______________________________________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Wednesday, May 7 -- 1:25 pm
By Zac Schultz

Madison: It appears the 911 Center made two crucial errors the day Brittany Zimmermann was murdered.

The first error prevented Zimmermann from getting police help immediately. The second error-just revealed Tuesday- ended up sending detectives down the wrong path for nearly two weeks.

Dane County Executive Kathleen Falk presented new information at a press conference Tuesday afternoon. Falk says the month-long internal investigation was completed Tuesday. She ran through it with the District Attorney and Madison Police to find out what details could be released without compromising the investigation.

Here's the background: On April 2nd, Brittany Zimmermann called 911 from her Doty St. apartment. The 911 dispatcher made three inquiries, heard nothing and then the call was ended. (Previously 911 Center Director Joe Norwick said the dispatcher hung up on Zimmermann, but now they say it is unclear, and they can only say the call ended.) The dispatcher moved on to a 911 hang up call.

According to policy, she should have called back Zimmermann's cell phone. Instead she called back the second hang up call and spoke to two men who said there was no emergency. She never called Zimmermann back. That was her first mistake.

The second mistake came when the 911 center later told police that the two men answered Zimmermann's cell phone.

911 didn't learn for 13 days that the men were from the second call and not related to the murder. But all the while detectives had been focused on finding these two men who where ultimately never connected to the murder.

The dispatcher said she heard nothing on Zimmermann's call, but police have said there were noises on the call that should have resulted in police being dispatched.

The next point of contention is where police would have been sent. Last week Joe Norwick said cell phone GPS technology was unreliable, and could have sent police miles away. The internal investigation shows police would have been sent to a building right next to Brittany Zimmermann's apartment, and the dispatcher could have used the cell phone provider to look up Zimmermann's real address within five minutes.

Chief of Police Noble Wray said last Thursday it was too soon to know if sending police would have saved Brittany's life, but Falk says no way. "From what I know, I do not believe Brittany Zimmermann's death could have been prevented."

Falk has now called for an external investigation by the Association of Public Safety Communications Officials.

She also wants the 911 center's oversight board to examine their policies.

The dispatcher has requested and received a transfer to another county department. She could still face discipline.

______________________________________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Tuesday, May 6 --- 4:45pm

MADISON, Wis. (AP) -- Dane County's top official says a better response to a 911 call from a college student before she was murdered still could not have saved her life.

County Executive Kathleen Falk apologized at a news conference for numerous errors employees made responding to the April 2 call from Brittany Zimmermann's cell phone.

But she says she does not believe the University of Wisconsin-Madison student's murder could have been prevented.

Falk says a county dispatcher inquired three times about whether an emergency existed but heard nothing before the call ended. She then failed to call the number back as required under department policy.

Falk says the call does contain sounds that have significance but they were not heard by the dispatcher.

Copyright 2008 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.

______________________________________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Tuesday, May 6 --- 4:10pm

The Press Conference by Dane County Executive Kathleen Falk is still underway.

However, she has already released several recommendations that she has made to the Director of the 911 Center:

- She requests that 911 administrators review current training and personnel qualifications.

- When an issue occurs about the sequence of several incoming phone calls in a short amount of time, 911 (administrators) should review as soon as possible all three sets of available records.

- With respect to the adequacy of existing technology, there is no fool proof ability to pinpoint where a cell phone call is originating. For land line phones, technology allows for accurate determination of the caller. With cell phone callers, the technology allows a location to be identified that may often be fairly precise but can on occasion range anywhere within a few miles of the actual caller.

- "Many people want a third party objective review of this situation and the overall performance of the 911 system. I think your report has identified the key concerns a review should consider. Please, as soon as possible, contact the Association of Public Safety Communication official (the national organization which sets the standards for 911 operations) and ask it to review this situation and the general performance of the 911 center."

______________________________________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Tuesday, May 6 --- 2:10pm

Dane County Board Chair Scott McDonell Issued this Press Release today. (Many of these items were reported Monday, by NBC15 News)

McDonell announced several steps the County Board will be taking to follow-up on the 911 Center’s involvement in the Brittany Zimmermann case:

• There will be a joint meeting of the Public Protection and Judiciary Committee and the Personnel and Finance Committee at 5:30 p.m. in Room 201 of the City County Building this Thursday, May 8th, 2008.

Emergency Communications Center staff will provide details of their investigation to the committees, and be available to respond to questions from county board supervisors. All county board supervisors are allowed to attend.

Parts of the meeting may be conducted in closed session, if necessary, in order to allow discussion of specific personnel or disciplinary issues or issues related to potential litigation.. All supervisors are allowed to remain in the room but may not divulge any information shared in closed session.

Madison City Channel, which is available on many cable TV systems throughout the county, has indicated they will carry the meeting live, and it will also be streamed live on the Internet at www.mcc12.tv.

• The County’s internal investigation of the 911 call from Ms. Zimmermann’s cell phone requested by the Madison Police Department will be completed in the next few days, and will be made available as soon as possible.

• County Board staff will review a study that was completed in 2004 by MTG Management Consultants, a Seattle, Washington consultant, to determine if recommendations have been implemented and whether the county needs to bring in an additional experts to review current operations. The Executive Committee will consider whether further audit attention in needed in coming weeks.

“Everyone in county government regrets the outcome of Brittany Zimmermann’s phone call to the 911 Center, and we are taking immediate steps to ensure there will not be a repeat of this occurrence,” said McDonell. “The County Board will get a report from Emergency Communications Center director Joe Norwick Thursday night, and then we will review the findings of the internal investigation and the MTG study that was completed in 2004. We will then determine whether additional county board action is necessary.”

McDonell also assured Dane County residents that they should continue to have confidence that their calls to the 911 Center will result in the assistance they need. The Center handles approximately 442 calls per day - over 161,000 calls in 2007 - with great accuracy. “Our citizens rely on the fact that when they call 911 for help, the call will result in emergency assistance being dispatched within minutes,” McDonell noted. “They should continue to have confidence in the public safety communication system.”

The Brittany Zimmermann murder has brought to light the limitations of cell phone technology for pinpointing the location of a caller in an emergency. It is important that the public be aware of how to place a 911 call in general, as well as understand that calling 911 from a cell phone is not like calling from a landline. If possible, it is best to use a landline when calling the 911 Center because the address of the call can be precisely located. However, many now depend on cell phones and, in some cases, the location of these calls cannot be exactly pinpointed with the current 911 technology.

“It is critical that people know what to do if calling for help,” McDonell said. Specifically:

• When calling 911, a caller will be asked for the address of the emergency, a call-back number, his or her name, and a description of what happened.

• If calling from a cell phone, the 911 Center has offered these guidelines - Assume the person taking the 911 call does not know your location and be prepared to work with them to determine the most accurate location where help is needed. Be prepared to give your cell phone number or some other way of re-contacting you. If the call is disconnected or if you are otherwise uncertain you’ve secured help, call 911 again.

• Call 911 if you need a assistance, but do not program it as a speed dial number. This will cut down on the number of calls made to the 911 Center in error.

Additional information regarding the ongoing investigation into the Brittany Zimmermann case will be posted on the county’s website (www.countyofdane.com), and will be updated as new information becomes available.

______________________________________________________________________________________________

UPDATE POSTED: Monday, May 5 -- 9:30pm
REPORTER: Brock Bergey

Dane County's top leader says it's time to apologize to the Brittany Zimmermann family.

Kathleen Falk says she's sending letters to the murdered college student's family and fiance.

She's not making the letters public at this time. However, she tells NBC 15 they will express -- "heart-felt compassion".

Falk says the 9-1-1 center made a mistake the day of Brittany Zimmermann's murder.

Last week, we learned a county dispatcher received a call, from Zimmermann's cell phone, on April 2nd, the same day the 21-year-old was found murdered in her Doty Street home.

Records show the dispatcher eventually hung up on the call and failed to place a call back, as is protocol.

On Thursday, when the news broke, 9-1-1 director, Joe Norwick said, then, no apology was needed.

However, Falk says the county is ready to take some responsibility.

"The 9-1-1 director has just completed the first phase of his investigation," she says. "And, now, based on what I know, I think we need to apologize to the Zimmermann family and Brittany's fiance, so I have drafted apology letters."

Falk says the letters will be delivered, soon, through the district attorney's office.

In addition to the apologies, Falk tells NBC 15 she will announce directives to the 9-1-1 director and staff, on Tuesday, to ensure something like this doesn't happen again.

She wouldn't elaborate any further on what those directives might be.

______________________________________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Monday, May 5 --- 4:35pm
By Zac Schultz

Madison: The 911 Center Director will testify in front of the County Board this Thursday

At issue; why a dispatcher hung up on Brittany Zimmermann's 911 call the day she was murdered.

Jack Martz has been a County Board Supervisor for six years.
He says he was blindsided last Thursday when he learned about Brittany Zimmermann's dropped 911 call. "I was totally surprised and quite frankly, flabbergasted."

That's why Martz and five other Supervisors wrote a letter asking for a special meeting so they could question Joe Norwick-the 911 Center Director. "I'm really interested in getting down to solving the problem. Getting the community back to feeling confident that if they call 911 something will happen," says Martz.

"The system has failed, and we have to find out why and what we're going to do to fix it," says Supervisor Dave Wiganowsky. He wants more than a hearing. "We want an external investigation in the department-or at least I do-to find out what went wrong."

Madison Police asked for an internal investigation April 2nd, the day Zimmermann was murdered. That was when they learned a dispatcher had hung up on Zimmermann's 911 call and ignored policy by not calling back.

Norwick met with the County Executive and the Board Chairman this afternoon, but he would not speak with media.

Board Chairman Scott McDonell says they asked about the investigation. "It's not quite complete, but it should be complete soon."

McDonell says they learned the dispatcher has changed jobs. "My understanding was that she requested a transfer. Given the circumstances that's not unreasonable."

The supervisors want to know what's taking so long. "I don't want to say that a month isn't long enough, but it sure appears to me that we should have had some answers," says Wiganowsky.

"If you haven't uncovered at least some of the issues that caused this problem in a month, then I'm wondering where you're looking," says Martz.

Thursday's County Board meeting with the 911 Center Director will take place at 5:30. McDonell says he's not sure if that internal investigation will be complete by then.

______________________________________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Monday, May 5 --- 3:45pm

From NBC15's Zac Schultz:
NBC15 News has learned the internal investigation into the botched 911 call made by Brittany Zimmermann is nearly complete. Also today, one County Board Supervisor is calling for an external investigation.

It's been more than a month since a 911 dispatcher hung up on Brittany Zimmermann the day she was murdered in her Doty Street apartment.

Madison Police asked for an investigation at the beginning of April, and now the Chairman of the County Board says he hopes the investigation will be wrapped up this week.

Last Thursday Joe Norwick, the 911 Center Director, admitted a dispatcher hung up on Zimmermann's cell phone because she didn't hear anything, and the dispatcher ignored policy and failed to call the cell phone back.

Now Dave Wiganowsky, Dane County Board Supervisor, wants an external investigation into the whole matter.

Wiganowsky says: "The problem happened, but my concern is how we're going to fix it. We're a month out right now. They can still keep the investigation going, but what we need to know is do we need to put help on more right now? Do we need to do it right away? Is this going to happen again?"

Earlier today, six members of the board demanded the chairman call a special meeting so they can get some answers. Late this afternoon, the chairman announced that this Thursday at 5:30pm, the 911 center director will testify before the board.

____________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Saturday, May 3 -- 8:00am

The Wisconsin State Journal is reporting that the 911 dispatcher who mishandled a call from Brittany Zimmermann's cell phone the day of her murder has been transferred to another Dane County Job.

According to the Journal, officials confirmed the dispatcher was transferred soon after the day of the murder, even though 911 center director Joe Norwick said they remained on the job Thursday.

____________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Friday, May 2 --- 5:35pm

From The Associated Press:
MADISON, Wis. (AP) -- Dane County's chief executive says authorities mishandled a 911 call from the cell phone of a college student but she has confidence in her 911 chief.

County Executive Kathleen Falk says "the system didn't work like it should" when a dispatcher received the call from Brittany Zimmermann's phone on April 2.

The dispatcher eventually hung up on the caller, failed to call the number back and never sent a police officer to investigate. Zimmermann was found murdered in her apartment shortly after.

Madison Police Chief Noble Wray says the 911 call contained evidence that should have triggered a dispatch but county authorities have described it as a routine "hang-up" call.

Falk praised Joseph Norwick, director of the county's 911 center, as a skilled law enforcement official.

_________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Thursday, May 1 --- 8:53pm

"It just gets to the point where you're kind of numb you know? It's like it hurts but what can you do?" says Zimmermann's best friend, Jenna Krasselt.

Krasselt would have been her future sister in law. She wants to keep her memory alive and reminisces about the friend she once had.

"She is a person you know, keep her dreams and her hopes I mean all the good she would have done for this world."

Jenna Krasselt knew Brittany best and still finds her tragic death hard to believe.

"A month ago I was one of those people you know? It's like you read about people something tragic has happened to. You've seen it on the news obviously and it's just like until it happens to you it's just one of those people you know?"

Together with the help of several of Brittany's friends a scholarship fundraiser has been setup to keep Brittany's name alive while benefitting the life of someone else. Those who knew her feel that it's least they can do for a girl who touched their life.

"She's my best friend you know? In a time like this it's like I wish I could do more for her."

If you'd like to contribute you can send a check or money order to

Marshfield medical Center CU
Attn: Dollars For Brittany
302 West Upham St.
Marshfield, WI 54449
(715)387-8686

_________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Thursday, May 1 --- 6:00pm

Madison: The UW student murdered in her apartment last month called 911, but the dispatcher never sent police.

The dispatcher actually hung up on Brittany Zimmermann because they didn't hear anybody on the other end of the line.

Brittany Zimmermann's body was found by her boyfriend around 1 pm on April 2nd in their Doty St. apartment. Police have released few details surrounding her murder but Thursday they confirmed a 911 call was placed from Zimmermann's cell phone the day she was killed. "It would be accurate to state that there is evidence contained in the call which should have resulted in a Madison Police Officer being dispatched," says Police Chief Noble Wray.

But an officer was never sent. Police aren't releasing details like when the call was made, how long it lasted, or even whether anything could be heard.

Joe Norwick is the Director of the 911 Communications Center. "The dispatcher answered this call and inquired several times to determine whether an emergency existed on the other end of the phone, and received no answer to the inquiries."

Norwick says the dispatcher actually hung up on Zimmermann, because there were two other 911 calls waiting. Norwick says the dispatcher was ok to hang up but they should have called back. "Under current policy, if dispatchers a 911 call and either don't hear a voice on the other end of the call or unable to determine if there is an emergency the dispatcher calls the number back."

But even if the dispatcher had called back, police would not have been sent, because Zimmermann called from a cell phone. Only calls from a landline get an automatic police visit, because 911 technology still can't give an exact location for a cell phone. "The accuracy of determining the origin of cell phone calls may range from within a city block to several miles."

Police Chief Noble Wray says the callback doesn't matter, the first call should have been enough. "There was evidence from the call that an officer should have been sent."

Norwick won't identify the dispatcher, only saying they are a competent veteran with a good record. "And of course that person feels very concerned over what happened."

Despite the fact police had to notify the 911 center about the dropped call Norwick is not ready to apologize, either to the Zimmermann family or the public.

Chief Wray says he asked Norwick to conduct an internal investigation a month ago. Norwick says that investigation is still ongoing and the dispatcher has not been reprimanded.

_________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Thursday, May 1 --- 2:50pm

Official Press Release from Madison Police Department:

During the course of the investigation into the murder of Brittany Sue Zimmermann, Madison Police detectives were able to determine a 911 call for service was made from Zimmermann's phone to the Dane County 911 center on April 2nd, 2008. That day the MPD brought this call to the attention of the Dane County 911 Center. Also on this day, Command Staff from MPD requested that the 911 Center not release information pertaining to this call. The request for non-disclosure has been reviewed throughout the investigation and is currently in force.

The MPD investigation also revealed that this was not an accidental 911 call, it was not an intentionally erroneous call, nor was it a hang-up call.

To protect the integrity of the Zimmermann case the exact contents of the open-line 911 call cannot be revealed. It would be accurate to state that there is evidence contained in the call, which should have resulted in a Madison police officer being dispatched. That would have been consistent with both Madison Police Department Policy, and national 911 standards. The 911 center did not call back to the telephone number, MPD was not notified of the call, and no officer was sent.

Shortly after the homicide Madison Police Chief Noble Wray recommended that the Dane County 911 Center conduct an internal investigation into what happened with this 911 call.

The MPD has enjoyed a good working relationship with the Dane County 911 Center, and is committed to continuing that relationship as we look to uphold public trust and confidence in our law enforcement system.

_________________________________________________________________

UPDATE Posted Thursday, May 1 --- 2:30pm

MADISON, Wis. (AP) -- Madison's police chief says an officer should have been dispatched to investigate a 911 call from a college student shortly before she was murdered.

Police Chief Noble Wray says the call from Brittany Zimmermann's cell phone contains evidence and should have been enough for a dispatcher to ask his department to send an officer.

He says the Dane County 911 Center never notified his agency and no officer was sent. He says he's concerned about the way the call was handled and asked for an internal investigation shortly after the April 2 murder of the University of Wisconsin-Madison student.

Zimmermann was murdered in her apartment while she was home alone. Police continue to search for her killer.

Copyright 2008 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.

Photo Courtesy of Facebook
Click Pictures to Enlarge
More Stories
Thanksgiving Weekend OWI Arrests

Sailor Missing from WWII is Identified

CrimeTracker 15: Two BB Gun Incidents: One Injured

Man Seriously Injured after Fall from Bike

CrimeTracker 15: Man Hospitalized Following Battery

CrimeTracker 15: Man Shot in Leg

More Snow Predicted for Wednesday

Winter Storm: Update from the City of Madison

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: S. Nguyen Location: Gaylord, MI on Nov 16, 2008 at 12:37 AM
Two times I called 911 in this area, two time I got cut off. People works there seems lazy, and always have bad days or something. They were ruth, did not want to listen what happen, they do all the talk, they ruthly hung up on me. I have never been disapointed like this in my life with 911 sevice. I always respect police officers, but I hate calling 911. I lost my trust with this station. I am sure I talked to the same women, same voice , same attitude. it was so distinct "ruth" that I cannot foget that voice. Why is she there if she doesn't want to help. If she had problem then go home, don't put on people who need help.

Posted by: Anonymous on May 25, 2008 at 11:47 PM
this is the one time they were caught not handleing it right how many times weren't they

Posted by: Schmitty on May 15, 2008 at 03:33 PM
"interesting", are you dense? That was my point. Innumerable posts on this very site have called 911 Center "the most useless", not to mention lazy, incompetent, etc. Yet they still sent the fire department!!! And from reading other current articles, they're still sending the police too!!!

Posted by: Anonymous on May 15, 2008 at 12:54 PM
I find it astounding that people and me included are still commenting. Who cares about dispatch and everything. Just for once can't the detectives surprise the community with an arrest? And the (right person/ people)in this case as well as the others. this is unbelievable. Oh I'm sorry, I almost forgot , Hey anon. If you can do a better job why don't you apply at the police dept.

Posted by: jj Location: sp on May 14, 2008 at 09:23 PM
I never slammed dispatch and I don't think it is her fault. However, this is NOT how they usually handle these kind of things. I am a former leo so I know what I'm talking about.

Posted by: Interesting on May 14, 2008 at 09:18 PM
Posted by: Schmitty on May 9, 2008 at 03:45 PM I hope no one here plans to ever call the "most useless 911 center." Ryan Brothers and Curtis are there if you have a medical emergency, JBM Security can handle anything you might need a police for, and if your house is on fire...hmmm I don't know who you're going to call. The most useless 911 center has NEVER once sent fire trucks to a fire, yes, because they are useless. I reply to Mr Schmitty here, ah who do you think everyone called when the frat house was on fire the other night? Glad you know the facts.

Posted by: scott Location: marshall on May 14, 2008 at 07:32 PM
None of these comments are going to solve the crime. Those of you crying out there, how many will be at the meeting on monday? This should be good.

Posted by: Greg P. on May 14, 2008 at 03:52 PM
I love how there will be a public hearing where everyone,including the user agencies, can slam dispatch. When is it the dispatcher's turn to speak? When do we get to slam the MPD, who are no treat to work with on the radio. And Carol? Yeah. Call Mike's Towing when your house is on fire or your husband stops breathing. That's a good solution and it's good that you shared that solution with the nbc15.com reading public.

Posted by: Anonymous on May 14, 2008 at 02:47 PM
I DON'T think it REALLY matter WHO the dispatcher was. I'm sure she feels bad enough with out having her name plasted all over the media. Also SLAMMING the 911 service is NOT RIGHT!!!! Hope you all who do the slamming NEVER need help!!!!

Posted by: jj Location: sp on May 10, 2008 at 09:45 PM
It will be very interesting to see who this dispatcher is. She is obviously a favorite, or somebody's wife or something. Otherwise, they would've thrown her to the wolves to get the press of the Dept's back. I would think under public record, they would HAVE to release her name.

Posted by: CAROL Location: Madison on May 10, 2008 at 06:23 PM
If you really need help call MIKES TOWING they will be there faster than the police!

Posted by: Schmitty on May 9, 2008 at 03:45 PM
I hope no one here plans to ever call the "most useless 911 center." Ryan Brothers and Curtis are there if you have a medical emergency, JBM Security can handle anything you might need a police for, and if your house is on fire...hmmm I don't know who you're going to call. The most useless 911 center has NEVER once sent fire trucks to a fire, yes, because they are useless.

Posted by: Concerned downtown patron Location: Madison on May 9, 2008 at 11:35 AM
Could the county government at least tell us their short term "911" solution. I don't have much confidence in their system right now. Put the finger pointing and covering up aside. Please explain your short term solution to an obvious flawed 911 sytem!

Posted by: jeannie Location: waunakee on May 9, 2008 at 09:59 AM
I think they need to stop with the 911 problem and find the killer they are wasting time and someone else is going to get hurt.

Posted by: Helen Location: Madison on May 9, 2008 at 09:29 AM
Scott: Mayor Dave needs to stand up. The MPD is not performing and Mayor Dave, as the leader of our City, is ultimately responsible for that. Stop apologizing for Mayor Dave and start asking some tough questions. Your sure he will get on the right people. Well, where is he? Who is he getting on? NOBODY.

Posted by: amazed Location: dane county on May 9, 2008 at 08:12 AM
"very informed on 911" - have you ever heard the word "hypocrisy"? Glad to see you feel you know everything about everyone who posts a topic. Now since you know everything about everyone, why not get off your can and go solve this crime?

Posted by: G on May 9, 2008 at 07:59 AM
very informed, your right!! Maybe we should help them start a school for crime solvers. They are obviously very smart and well informed. Most of them watch CSI you know. Wait a minute...that's it... lets call in Caruso.

Posted by: gary Location: Madison on May 9, 2008 at 07:30 AM
Very imformed, Yeah it is prety sweet! I find your comments to be rather funny. Not EVERYONE on here is a gas station attendant, check out clerk or what have you. Those remarks make you an easy target. I, for one, am college educated and find the many blunders surrounding this case to be inexcusable. If I were to have made such am error at my place of employment, I would have at the very least been reprimanded, which according to all the "higher up's" she wasn't. Do not assume everyone who puts posts on here are uneducated idiots. Do you work at the 911 center or have a spouse or family member that does? I still say, if the pressure or stress of the job is too much for the dispatcheer, maybe they should find another job so innocent people will get the response they need, want and so very much need will be answered and nobody else will have to hear any more LAME excuses such as those you have pointed out.

Posted by: Anonymous on May 9, 2008 at 06:24 AM
To ver informed in 911 at 7:49pm- No one is claiming to be an expert but, we are trying to make sure this doesn't happen to some other family. And home schooled isn't the answer since you spelled it wrong.

Posted by: Anonymous on May 8, 2008 at 11:05 PM
very informed, do you not understand that there is a killer on the loose? and face it, MPD's track record of finding killers isn't anything to brag about. the public is frustrated with the way these investigations are being conducted. its time to start asking questions and stop taking their word for it. it's their job to catch criminals and since they can't, theyre not doing their job and need to be replaced by people who are capable of doing this.

Posted by: T on May 8, 2008 at 09:08 PM
Very MISinformed 7:49p.m. you are a complete idiot. It's a wonder you work at 911 most useless dispatch center. Please due the public a favor and put your kid into public school. When they say to "break the cycle" hopefully your kid does not follow in your foot steps . you are a complete fool!

Posted by: Susan on May 8, 2008 at 08:53 PM
Well Anonymous (May 8, 12:29pm) I guess no one supports Brittany or cares to stand up for what's right, under your definition. I was at that meeting, and 15 public attendees is probably generous. Were you there?

Posted by: scott Location: marshall on May 8, 2008 at 08:42 PM
Enough already. You all shooting off your mouths when none of us the complete story. None of us know any thing for sure except we can't bring her back. No one knows if officers had arrived after the 911 call, if her life would have been saved! A good chance of possibly catching someone? Maybe. Only those who are involved with the case(ray,mpd detects,911 head) should apoligize for mistake they make. Not mayor dave. The people that should be checking into the mistakes are doing so. If the mayor does'nt like it I'm sure he'll get on the right people. You delegate then let them lead. All of you who are screaming about info here info there, need to wait till the full report comes out. Patience is a virtue.

Posted by: very informed on 911 Location: Dane co. on May 8, 2008 at 07:49 PM
It's prety sweet how everyone is an expert on this subject....but don't know anything about it. But thats ok, go back to your gas station attendant job, your check out job at the local food mart, your secretary job, your 9-5 job and feel good about yourselves......cause you know everything. And since you do, can I send my kid to you to be home schooleed...because I want him to learn from the best.

Posted by: Timothy Location: Madison on May 8, 2008 at 02:48 PM
I have to agree with Helen, Mayor Dave has been silent. I don't understand why the media is not questioning him about the MPD failures. Cassie is correct, lets focus on those that are not getting the job done. As every day goes by, it gets harder and harder to solve this crime. Instead of "Where's Waldo" we should have a "Where's Mayor Dave"

Posted by: Helen Location: Madison on May 8, 2008 at 01:36 PM
When is Mayor Dave going to apologize for the incompetence of Noble Wray and the detectives on this case and others. I don't have an issue with the patrol officers but I have a problem with those who are managing and leading the recent murder investigations. Do you think Mayor Dave has a pillow under his desk so he can be more comfortable in the fetal position.

Posted by: Cassie Location: Madison on May 8, 2008 at 01:29 PM
My comment follows many below, why divert the focus of this issue onto the 911 operator? Why not take all this time and energy and focus on finding out who did this. I am sure the 911 operator is not the only one who MAY have made an error. The responsibility to find who did this is the police, the 911 call is a missed opportunity now, over and done with, what would you have done with it anyway? Arrived maybe 30 minutes later to investigate a hangup call and found poor dead Brittney before her boyfriend? The fact of the matter is no one has found out who has done this and like 3 other murder cases in the recent past, probably won't be solving it anytime soon. Think of how many lives this operator has saved in her career - now the media, county, police are placing all there energy on this call that may or may not have made a difference? Who had the stupid idea to give this information to the press anyway? Share it with the family, yes - the world - NO. For everyone, Just find who did it

Posted by: Anonymous on May 8, 2008 at 12:29 PM
If People Live within 45 minutes of where this meeting is and you are not working or do not have a REAL EMERGENCY, YOU ARE NOT SHOWING SUPPORT FOR BRITTANY AND DO NOT CARE ABOUT STANDING UP FOR WHATS RIGHT!! PERIOD!! THE ONLY THING YOU PEOPLE CARE ABOUT IS SHOOTING OFF YOUR BIG USELESS MOUTH ON A STUPID SCREEN!!!I WOULD THEN SAY YOU ARE PART OF THE PROBLEM AS WELL!!!

Posted by: Anonymous on May 8, 2008 at 09:32 AM
YES! the media is the only way we are going to get heard about any of this. Start playing hardball already and put these idiots that run madison in the hot seat. ive seen how running one story on the news can change things drastictly. you have the power media (nbc 15)

Posted by: Anonymous on May 8, 2008 at 08:30 AM
Maybe MORE time should be placed on trying to find out WHO did this terrible crime than on HOW the 911 call was handled!!

Posted by: Dont Matter Location: Madison on May 8, 2008 at 07:57 AM
The Media in this city needs to get out of bed with the police and politicians. Any other media in any other city would attack these incompetants until they were forced to resign. Why won't are media do its job? These people should never be allowed to lead anyone. Also get a police chief that will whip these lazy and dumb cops into shape

Posted by: Gene Location: madison on May 8, 2008 at 07:43 AM
Is there any more of a way to make Madison the laughing stock of the country? Our leaders are a bunch of out of touch jokers! Kathleen Falk, you should be ashamed of yourself for the rediculous comments you made. Your assuming that even if the call would have been handled properly, the killer still would not have been caught? That assumption on your behalf demonstrates what a bunch of gomers we have as leaders. You did it this time Kathy! Put one foot in your mouth and another up your rear! Great job!! Good thing I am not the father of this woman. I think I would have payed a visit to both you and that moron 911 Director. And I would surely be talking to an attorney!!

Posted by: Anonymous on May 8, 2008 at 06:41 AM
I think it is disgusting how the union reps back how the 911 call was handled. You explain that to the family- that you think it was ok that no one followed up with their dying daughter. Disgusting- and you wonder why people think the only purpose of a union is to protect the guilty.

Posted by: OMG on May 7, 2008 at 09:07 PM
Muffled sounds on a 911 cell call usually means the phone is in someone's pocket. But if you want 911 to listen to that for hours while ignoring other calls, send cops all over town trying to find everyone with a cell phone in their pocket or purse, knock yourself out. By the way subscriber name has to be subpoenaed from the provider, and they need a darn good reason to answer that subpoena. No sound and muffled sounds don't qualify.

Posted by: Anonymous Location: madison on May 7, 2008 at 08:21 PM
NBC 15 needs to start posting some of these comments on news telecasts. Something needs to be done about the people that run this city. Venting on here is good but what else can be done by the general public to see some results? All anyone has been doing lately is passing the blame on to someone else or another department. How many people have to die before changes are made? you seriously cannot make this stuff up.

Posted by: gym on May 7, 2008 at 08:15 PM
I can't bear to imagine poor Brittney clinging to the desperate hope that the 911 operator who took her call understood by the sounds on the other end of the line that she was in trouble and in dire need of help. Afterall, barely audible, muffled sounds or no sounds at all should send up the alert that the caller on the other end of the line is in the midst of a critical situation, shouldn't it? I mean, someone is in your house looking to harm you, you're hiding and manage to dial 911 but you're afraid to say anything lest you give away your location. Come on......... Is this not a real scenario....a scenario of your worst nightmare? But instead the 911 operator hangs up on you (or the dispatcher "heard nothing and then the call was ended"). So, so sad and maybe even preventable.

Posted by: jj Location: sp on May 7, 2008 at 07:03 PM
I think it is quite obvious that Dane Co has screwed this up from the get go and they are more busy trying to cover their a** instead of trying to solve this murder. Their best bet would be to turn it over to a different agency. I hope her family sues the h--- out of the County. As a Mom, my heart aches for her mom knowing the at she called 911 for help and was hung up on.

Posted by: jj Location: sp on May 7, 2008 at 06:58 PM
Everyones too afraid to back me because they don't want to lose thier jobs. Been trying to get the local news to start something but no luck. Too political.

Posted by: Anonymous on May 7, 2008 at 06:56 PM
Norwick needs to be removed from his post - IMMEDIATELY. The delay caused by this debacle was critical, and the murderer(s) may never be found now. I hope I'm wrong about that. Falk, I'm extremely disappointed in your stubborn defense of Norwick - he won't be demoted or fired?!? I'll make sure to vote for the other person when you're up for re-election. I hope that, whomever that is, will have the sense to remove dead weight from the 911 center.

Posted by: rose Location: madison on May 7, 2008 at 05:43 PM
I make my living off the evening news, just give me something, something I can use. People love it when you lose, they love dirty laundry. I could have been an actor, but I wound up here. I just have to look good I don't have to be clear. Come and whisper in my ear, give us dirty laundry. Kick em when they're up, kick em when they're down. (lyrics from "Dirty Laundry" by Don Henley) Not sure how the media is helping and hope everyone knows that what happened can't be taken back. People can be held accountable without being ripped apart.

Posted by: Mike Location: Bristol on May 7, 2008 at 04:49 PM
I watch a lot of CSI: Miami (even re-runs) and if they were in charge this all would have been solved by now. It's obvious that a lot of my fellow posters watch it too when they aren't busy perfectly performing their jobs. If Kathleen keeps flapping her jaws and ends up costing Dane Co. a huge settlement maybe she could get an acting job on CSI to help pay for it.

Posted by: George Location: Verona on May 7, 2008 at 03:38 PM
Norwick is obviously an idot, and so is Kathleen. Now lets start concentrating on solving these murders. Obviously Madison needs some assistance. Maybe the FBI could lend a hand?????

Posted by: Steven on May 7, 2008 at 01:55 PM
I think thats also a good idea JJ, Why don't you show everyone whos in charge! Go back to your employer and knock the daylights out of all the bullies!! I bet you'd have more people backing you up than what you realize!

Posted by: Anonymous on May 7, 2008 at 01:26 PM
"BUT IT CERTAINLY WOULD HAVE PUT THE POLICE AT THE SCENE MINUTES AFTER NOT HOURS AFTER." Actually, the police also connected the wrong suspects to the crime. They held them for almost two weeks on murder charges when it was the wrong 911 call. I bet it was the guys attorneys who figured it out, not even the police! This is bigger that we think! But I don't want Falk spending a million dollars of tax money for her stupid study! She just needs to go. The people who get her job can do the research in their spare time!

Posted by: Anonymous on May 7, 2008 at 01:17 PM
I being a parent that recieves child support am not happy that they moved here to that department. What is she going to do next, misplace child support payments. If this would be a police office, they would have been fired on the spot.

Posted by: B Location: MADISON on May 7, 2008 at 12:57 PM
How does she know it wouldn't have prevented it? They don't know who killed her, they don't know when it happened exactly. What a stupid thing for her to say. I typically like her, but this was just stupid.

Posted by: Anonymous on May 7, 2008 at 12:33 PM
Hey JJ, Thats a good idea. Make an example outta that crooked department you worked for!

Posted by: Anonymous on May 7, 2008 at 11:46 AM
The murder may not have not been prevented, but they may have been able to catch the killer.

Posted by: JJ Location: Dane on May 7, 2008 at 09:47 AM
Fire the Dispatcher? Just taking orders from her Peers.It all starts at the top.Fire Falk and work your way down.

Posted by: JJ Location: Dane on May 7, 2008 at 09:46 AM
Falk would say anything to get the blame off of her.Solutions not excuses.We need new Leadership !!

Posted by: Pam on May 7, 2008 at 09:45 AM
The police and Falk say even if the right procedure would have been followed, the result would have most likely been the same, EXCUSE ME!!! How do they know that. She may have been hurt, but any interruption in the crime could have saved her life. I feel so bad for the family to think their daughter tried to get help and it was ignored. The 911 operator should be fired, her carelessness caused this young girl her life or at least a better chance at solving the crime.

Posted by: Anonymous on May 7, 2008 at 09:23 AM
JJ, Have you ever thought about ambushing the department you worked for if thats truelly the case?

Posted by: Anonymous on May 7, 2008 at 09:15 AM
As I'm punching this in, there are currently 325 comments. I would like to know what is really go to change if anything about the dispatch system, and what information they have in solving the unsolved crimes. To VERY MISinformed on 911. 11:34p.m. People have been making it clear for starters that when someone goes into the field of Law Enforcement they have intentions of making a difference. For you to start foaming at the mouth about stress and anything else you want to jawjack about, what I want to know is who twisted your arm and told you , you need to go into dispatching for the 911 center? Furthermore "Mis Informed on 911, your personality and comments about the daily aspects of the 911 center speaks volumes on how I personally would look at a dispatcher in the 911 system from now on. MORON!!

Posted by: Anonymous on May 7, 2008 at 08:44 AM
THIS MARKS THE END OF MRS FALK'S POLITICAL CAREER. MAY NOT HAVE STOPPED HER FROM BEING KILLED, BUT IT CERTAINLY WOULD HAVE PUT THE POLICE AT THE SCENE MINUTES AFTER NOT HOURS AFTER.

Posted by: Anonymous on May 7, 2008 at 07:42 AM
We are not bashing the police here. It is the management of the whole program. Falk is out licking ankles again as usual. Her staff is supporting her, gee-I wonder why? They like their "do-nothing" jobs. The police are underfunded and the mayor is under his desk in a fetal position (I liked that comment! It describes him well.) Falk is going to hire and outside contractor to do an audit. Wow, she is going to spend more tax money on a "STUDY." Oh, how we could use those millions of dollars in better ways. Let's elect dedicated politicians next time: Can we find a Bob Proxmire, or a Gaylord Nelson? We can't afford "administrators" any more. Their sole job, in the state and at the University, is to "Cover the Boss's A--!" Do you know that the normal pay for an "Administrator" starts at over $80,000.00 per year? A good German Shepard would be less expensive than that!

Posted by: Gary Location: Madison on May 7, 2008 at 07:19 AM
Hey "what the heck". Are you really as out of touch as you seem? I mean really, why should the dispatcher NOT be fired along with all the other "higher ups" in this department? They totally all but ignored recommendations put forth by a review committee. The dispatcher FAILED to follow protocol and DID NOT call back. Just because cell phones cannot be pin pointed to an address do not mean they can just ignore procedures. They (Dane County 911) tried to "sweep this under a rug" in hopes it never be leaked out. If it were not for the Isthmus, this may have never been brought to light. Before spouting off, maybe you should read ALL of the reports, not just what you want.

Posted by: Anonymous on May 7, 2008 at 06:28 AM
Rich McVicar seems to think that there was no issue on how the 911 call was handled according to news reports. Sounds like we need someone else in charge of the 911 center and quick. To think she called and couldn't speak and no one followed up is terrible. It doesn't matter if they think it wouldn't have made a difference in her death. You should have tried.

Posted by: C Location: Madison on May 7, 2008 at 05:55 AM
Me-You also have to understand that although the cell phone may have given the address next door, when you are dealing with multi-story buildings and a 3 block radius, many, many people could be in that area. It's not as easy as just knocking on the door next to the address that came up on the 911 screen. There would have been no way for the dispatcher to know that the victim was right next door to the address that came up on her screen. She could have only pinpointed it to a 3 block radius.

Posted by: C Location: Madison on May 7, 2008 at 05:52 AM
Me-it's not that easy. Di