UPDATE: Fitchburg Smoking Ban Save Email Print
Reporter: Brock Bergey
Email Address: bbergey@nbc15.com

A | A | A

UPDATE: Tuesday, April 1, 2008 -- 4:30pm

No smoking signs replace the ashtrays at Kelly's Grille and it's no April Fool's Day joke.

"Generally, when we come in, we have to search for a spot that's smoke-free," says one Kelly's regular customer. "Now, we don't have to worry about that."

While that's true at Kelly's, four Fitchburg businesses still cater to smokers.

"There's absolutely no reason to favor one business over the other," says Fitchburg Alder Steve Arnold.

He says all public places in the city should clear the air.

"Many times you will hear people say, well, let the marketplace decide and the government shouldn't intervene," Arnold says. "Yet, how can the government go in and protect the public health, in almost all the establishments, but leave out four?"

The city granted two bars and a bowling alley three year exemptions. A cigar bar has a permanent pass, under the current local legislation. (See list below.)

Fitchburg's mayor says the breaks are to prevent businesses from going out of business.

Even though it's not 100-percent, the grassroots group, Smoke-Free Fitchburg sees this as a victory for public health.

"It's like if someone wants to eat some fattening food," says spokesperson Alice Jenson. "The only person that person is hurting is himself. But, the smokers are hurting themselves and everyone else around them."

Jenson says Fitchburg has done what the state has failed to do. A feat the diners, we spoke with, appreciate.

"Being a college student, I'm around it enough. When you go out to eat, you don't have to smell it."

Right now, four Wisconsin communities, including Madison, ban smoking in all public places.

Tuesday evening, the Middleton City Council is taking up the issue. Restaurants in Middleton are already smoke-free, but lighting up is currently allowed in bars.

***FITCHBURG SMOKING BAN EXEMPTIONS***
-Monkeyshines (three years)
-Schneid's Sports Bar & Grill (three years)
-Ten Pin Alley (three years)
-Hemingway Lounge (permanent)

_______________________________________________________________
POSTED: Monday, March 31, 2008 -- 9:30pm

The cigarettes are about to be put out for good in Fitchburg. At midnight, April 1st, the city's restaurants and bars go smoke-free

The beginning of the Brewers season marks the end of a game-time ritual for some baseball fans.

"The last day of smoking in here," says Mark Denhart. "I have to enjoy it while I have the chance."

Denhart lives in Madison, but frequents Fitchburg bars, like the Great Dane where he can light a cigar--that is until the clock strikes 12.

"When we open for business (Tuesday), there will be signs up letting people know," says General Manager Scott Simmerman.

Simmerman says he's ready to do away with his upstairs smoking section.

"I would say about 40-percent of the patrons up here, on the weekends, are smokers," he says.

But, Simmerman's not worried about losing business. He's expecting a different trend.

"There's a lot of the population that wants to go out but didn't in the past because of smoking," he adds.

Fitchburg will become the 32nd Wisconsin community to enact some form of a smoking ban.

It includes a few exemptions. The mayor telling NBC 15 News he didn't want to shut down any businesses.

Meantime, ashtrays at the Great Dane move to an outside patio where smoking will remain legal.

Back inside, Simmerman says some physical changes are on the way, like new carpet.

"Get kind of the smell out of the air," says Simmerman.

"Yes, I'll still come here, probably not as often," says Denhart.

He says he's heard the arguments and believes this is government going too far.

"People should be able to smoke, it's a legal product, you know, that's the way it is," he adds.

On the same day Fitchburg's ban takes effect, Middleton takes up the issue.

Tuesday night, the city council will consider drafting an ordinance to prohibit smoking in bars. Middleton already bans cigarettes in restaurants.

Meantime, Monona has formed a committee to discuss a proposed smoking ban.

More Stories
Special Assignment: An Ironman Challenge for MS

Special Assignment: Hope in the Face of MS

Tammy's Curry Recipes

Oral Cancer Cases Up

Smoking Bans & Drunk Driving

UPDATE: Fitchburg Smoking Ban

Madison Ranks #1 for TEETH

Morning After Pill

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: dd on Apr 5, 2008 at 01:50 PM
I do not get it. There is places for all you non smokers to go that is smoke free. GROW UP AND GO TO ONE OF THE SMOKE FREE BARS. WHO MADE YOU ALL GOD!

Posted by: Teri on Apr 2, 2008 at 02:11 PM
Everyone has a right to smoke. That's where it stops. Your rights shouldn't come before or after ours (non-smokers). That being said, consider bars and other public places neutral sites if you will and get past this stupid my right, no right, up right down right prattle... No one should be forced to tolerate smoking and to have any kind of social life in the areas that still allow smoking means no bars, no bowling, no clubs... How is that considered fair and equal? As I said, let's just consider these PUBLIC places neutral and stop the incessant bickering...

Posted by: Anonymous on Apr 1, 2008 at 07:53 PM
Hey Brenda just so you know I'm having fun with you. I WAS A SMOKER about 10 years ago. I recall buying Marlboro 100's at almost $5.oo pack. When I went to a convienience store, the guy paid $3-4.00 per pack. It seems the price has gone down somewhat ya know. On the New Jersey turnpike 8.75 per pack.

Posted by: Anonymous on Apr 1, 2008 at 05:27 PM
To Brenda the smoking queen, I think the other A N O N Y M O U S at 12:34p.m. said it best!

Posted by: brenda on Apr 1, 2008 at 04:06 PM
anomyous,.,, your a smart one.... as i was a child and did not smoke, you get an idiot fee

Posted by: BB on Apr 1, 2008 at 03:10 PM
Anonymous 9:25a.m. Part of the problem would be fixed if you would kindly put the catalytic converter back on your car!

Posted by: Anonymous on Apr 1, 2008 at 02:01 PM
Hey Brenda, the smoking queen. Maybe your grandparents died being around smokers such as yourself.

Posted by: Tina on Apr 1, 2008 at 01:46 PM
it really is idiotic to say that people who drink in bars are comparable to those who smoke -- funny, but before the smoking ban in Madison, I'd go out to hear live music (which I love) and end up sick and stinky every time from the ridiculous amounts of smoke -- but nobody ever forced alcohol into my system. and to those who say their parents smoked and aren't sick, well they're just lucky ... come talk to my COPD-ridden grandparents if you want a different take on reality!

Posted by: Anonymous on Apr 1, 2008 at 12:34 PM
To everyone who smokes. Please take yourself, your cigarettes, and your bad breath out to the hills.

Posted by: Anonymous on Apr 1, 2008 at 12:25 PM
Hey anon. You don't have any right to smell up my fresh air.

Posted by: Anonymous on Apr 1, 2008 at 12:13 PM
Yay! Looks like I'll be going to Fitchburg bars more often! Hopefully Monona and Middleton will follow suit.

Posted by: brenda on Apr 1, 2008 at 12:03 PM
SOOOOOOOO TIRED OF government PICKING THE POCKETS OF SMOKERS FOR UNESSECARY TAX DOLLARS. but tell us we cant smoke anywhere. If we are paying the bills why take our rights away. We are americans too. Where are you going to get the extra revenue if we all stop somking and paying the bills for the state at more than $1.00 a pack! HUH? You all SMOKE FREE FREAKS begin to pay and how much whining when take place then.... HUH??? Both my grandparents never ever smoked and died of heart desease and cancer... explain that????

Posted by: Holly on Apr 1, 2008 at 10:22 AM
I can understand why a lot of people are upset over this but in response to Anonymous at 10:55 PM, sometimes I go out to have a drink or two and that's it. I choose to go drink, not breathe in secondhand smoke. You are still getting to choice to smoke, you just have to go outside. It's not like someone is telling you that you can never smoke again. If I go to a bar that allows smoking, I'm choosing to drink but forced to breathe in smoke. Is it fair to nonsmokers to stay home just because they don't like to smell smoke?

Posted by: Anonymous on Apr 1, 2008 at 09:25 AM
Yes, clean Air is everyone's right. But why pick on the smokers. Is it because we are easy Targets? If one deosn't like smoking, then they should stay Home, or better yet, go to places that are smoke free. But Bars should be exempt from this non sense. Take care of the real Problem here, which is DRINKING. The smokers are NOT alone the Problem for Air Polution. There are also the exhausts from Cars/Busses, all that stuff that comes out of certain Chimneys. Stop wasteing our Tax Money, and get to the root of the real Problem.

Posted by: Anonymous on Apr 1, 2008 at 07:53 AM
Down Smoking, and encourage Drinking. Our Law makers are so inconsidered.

Posted by: Anonymous on Apr 1, 2008 at 12:40 AM
Maybe it is time for tobacco to become illegal throughout Wisconsin then. If you want to smoke it (or heaven forbid, chew it) then you need to go to Michigan, Minnesota, Iowa or Illinois to do it. Then the no-smoking issue will become moot. You can't ingest tobacco legally in any form after that. No more "right to smoke" arguments then!

Posted by: D on Mar 31, 2008 at 11:45 PM
It's funny how these bleeding heart liberals love to mandate the same type of government they protest. Way to go! You have become the problem, not the solution.

Posted by: Anonymous on Mar 31, 2008 at 10:55 PM
People have the right to smoke. It's legal and it's someone's choice. Just like it's also a choice to go out to bars where it is known that people will be smoking.

Posted by: Anonymous on Mar 31, 2008 at 10:02 PM
Hurray!! Fresh air at last! there have been so many times I wondered why I got cleaned up before going out. Just to go back home to get cleaned up again.